My opinion
Well, this is my first time postng anything in this area. The reason for that is, i imagine, basically because i'm Canadian. I admit i'm greatly saddend by what has happened to the United state's, and there is no doutd that it is a horrible Tragedy. I know that this tragedy will have reprocussions around the world and has touched many people. But i know my feelings are some what different to a point, or atleast not as strong as the Americans.
Not because i dislike the united states or it's people, but because it's in another country. I don't know anybody who was hurt, and i have no family up there. The next day, i neither saw the rubble or the sight of rescue workers. It was for all purposes, with the exception of the new's over the radio, a reguler day for me.
Before you judge me to harshly, ask yourselves, how many times you have heard of innocent people being killed in the news? How many times have you heard of innocent people being bombed, then cried tears of blood for them? for those of you who have, i applaud your empathy. Your kind will be the way of the future. For those who haven't i suppose your like me. A person, who unless directly involved, see's it as still as a great tragedy, but has a certain degree of detachment, or less emotional involvement.
Or Perhaps i have just been using that as some sort of twisted comfort. The fact that it IS another country and not my own. Perhaps that has placed me in some sort of denial. If it were my own i'm sure i would feel different. Perhaps other poeple from other Countries would know what i mean. I don't know if that makes me a bad person. Something i've been asking myself whenever the topic comes up. In time i hope i find the answer.
The only reason i'm posting on this particuler post is, unlike the others that seem to only direct to America to some point, a war would include everybody. I just thought i would bring up a few scary thoughts i've been having.
A) first of, terrism isn't a war we can win. It never will be. As somebody in this thread pointed out, as long as there are unhappy people in the world, terrism will exist. It's really as simple as that. We can close up the border's to our countries and not let anybody in, and have constant boat and airship patrol's over our countires, but really, if there's a will, there will be a way. Perhap's not all the time, but it only takes one careless person to cause such disaster. Sure, we can kill hundred's of thousand's of people, but will it actually do anything, or will it simply leave more terrorists in it's wake with simply nothing to loose anymore?
B) Bin Ladon. Now, this has pretty much became the assumption of the world who did it. and it certainly does point towards him, although i admit i haven't heard a deffinit yes or no as to whether it actually was him. Until then, i will keep my mind open to other possibilities. The simple facvt about this man, other then the fact that he seem's both intelegent and patient, is that he's a religious leader. Now, many might not think much of that, but from what i can tell it also means his follower's are religiouse fanatics. This put's them in a different place then the average soldier, espicially when you figure that they've been trained in Terrism tactics for a long time. Religiouse fanatics are willing to die as easily as they are willing to pick up there gun. That little fact, in itself, is scary.
C) Nukes. Now, that is a word that is very scary, just by itself. The fact that there are so many of them is even scarier. And finally, the thought of a religiouse Fanatc with a nuke, is probably the scarriest thought of all. I'd be willing to put down money that the US won't use Nukes. For a lot of reasons. Good Reasons. I think all of them have pretty much been said already in the forum. now, Bin Laden on the other hand, would have none of those problems. hopefully though, he doesn't have any.
D) Another point that nobody has brought up yet is the posibility of Chemical weapons. Now, i'm not sure where i heard it, but i do remember hearing that they've been working on chemical weapons over there for some time now. The last thing i want is this world becoming an episode of "The Stand".
So, the question is, where do i stand? Do i believe that there should be a war? No. A war, by any justifications, is still a war. And you can be sure that there will be many more dead people before it's over. Should it be just let be then? No. Not for vengenace though. But because of what else Bin Laden is capable of doing. a men like him, with his abilities, is a scary thought.
My solution? That's a tricky question. In my opinion, the focus should be on capturing Bin Laden, not on seeing how many Afganistans we can kill. Some might agree with me, but i know there are other's out there who just want to destroy Afganistan totally. Violence breeds violence, vengence breeds vengence. It is a viciouse cycle that can become very strong very fast.
If you blow up afganistand, what's to stop Mr Akbar, whose been working in the Nuclear plant for the last twenty years and is a model Employ, from snapping when he finds out his family, which had nothing to do with the destruction of the world trade center or the pentagon, and simply coming in one day and pressing a few wrong buttoms? (I know i'm over simplifying there, but you get the point)
I have said everything i have had to say. Perhaps what i have said, some people will not like. That is up to them, i never posted with the intention of upsetting people. I have spoken what i believe is the truth, and i have put a great deal of thought and time into this post. My opinion may change, just like anybody elses. Some may wonder why i posted this. I could have simple planted my reasons, A-D, against war. It would have been a great deal easier and less time consuming. It certainly wasn't to become more populer, and in fact it may very well cost me friends and respect that i have made on this forum. For some reason though, i felt the need to type this. Perhaps this is my own way of coping, of dealing with the insanity that threatens to take hold of us all. I will let the American people be my judge, and if they feel the need, my executioner.
Sincerly Cosmo_ac