When it comes to which current women I think are the most ticklish? Going by admissions, in no order
Ronda Rousey - Violently ticklish
Natalya - Very ticklish, too ticklish for massages
Nikki and Brie Bella - based off of their own ratings
Becky Lynch - Armpit poked and immediately jerked away
Mandy Rose - Tickled by Sonya, pedicures tickle
Paige - Tickled multiple times
Thea Trinidad - Hates being tickled
As for the past
Mickie James - Very ticklish on sides and feet
Torrie - Also very ticklish on sides and feet, becomes more ticklish if she's feeling silly.
Lita - 50/50 ticklishness but will squirm desperately if being tickled on her feet
Emma - Really ticklish
Melina - So ticklish it hurts, feet are sensitive to pedicures causing her to yank her foot away
Maryse, Michelle McCool, Kelly Kelly - All have ticklish feet, laugh when getting pedicures
Trish Strauts - Apparently lost every time she started tickle fights with other Divas
Jillian Hall & Lilian Garcia - Ticklish when getting pedicures
AJ Lee - Too ticklish for massages, Big E apparently tickled her feet before