one thumb, way down
I saw "Rent" on Broadway several years back. I didn't care for it (although my opinion certainly doesn't always coincide with the masses) and was unsure what all the hype was about. The impression I left the theatre with was that the musical seemed to think that it was somehow on the cutting edge- that it was the first to embrace the radical idea of being a 'rock musical.' I felt that GodSpell, Hair, Jesus Christ Superstar, the Wiz, and other 70s musicals were much, much better examples of the genre. And while I'm not a big fan of musicals, I do like the ones that I listed above and felt like they offered something of quality and something with energy and excitement, musically-speaking. They were fun, and they were different. The only memorable song from 'Rent,' for me, was the featured ballad- can't remember the title.