Do you think Manning deserves a SuperBowl Ring?

[ticklingfeet4fu]

Deserve it??? I thought you earned it??? If he doesn't earn it, then what do you think. If he thinks he deserves one then he needs to find out where all these guys pawn their rings when they need money and buy it. Otherwise, go out and play for it. He has choked in every big spot imaginable.

 

[kis123]

This coming from a Chiefs fan thats team gose nowhere season after season. tell you what you worry about your team and I'll worry about mine. but one day Eli will get his Ring

The only award Eli Manning deserves is "biggest baby in the history of the NFL draft." When you're drafted, you go where you're told. Instead he cries until he gets his way. I can't stand crybaby men and Eli's the worst IMO!

I like Peyton Manning, but the Colts will win almost every game in a season and choke in the playoffs. Maybe this year they'll be better and go all the way.

 

[pghtickleguy]

In my opinion I don't think Peyton will ever win a championship. The key word in win and add to that a winner. He has all the talent in the world but he isn't a winner. Go back to his college days. Tennessee had a very good team and they didn't win with him but the very next year with Tee Martin they win the title. They had the same team and Tee Martin won it for them. He was drafted by the Steelers the next year and has been out of football for a few years. How can Tee Martin lead a team to a championship and Peyton can't? Look at last year in the playoffs for the Colts. Peyton got to a point where he went against the coach on a 4th down play and shooed his special teams off the field. Look where it got them. He is unfortunately on a team that has a defense of swiss cheese but still I just don't think he has what it takes to win. Eli as soon as he matures will be fine. I still think he is the most talented out of the quarterback pack that came out a few years ago and we even have Big Ben who has done the most out of all of them so far. Time will tell......

 

[Tickle Fiend]

Thought I would bump this thread, even though, as we all know, the original point of the thread is now moot.

Now the real question is, can Peyton repeat and put himself in the same company as the other all time championship QB's like Bradshaw, Montana, Brady, and Aikman? All of whom won multiple Super Bowls.

I think he'll win two, but I'm just glad he won one. I just don't think he'll get another one until the end of his career.