Erza Scarlet & Mirajane Strauss (Fairy Tail): The Tickle Contest 1/2
By MrObscura101
The Fairy Tail Guild hall…
“I’m sorry, would you like to repeat that?” Erza Scarlet said as her eyes narrowed
“Oh sorry, did I stutter?” Mirajane Strauss replied with a wry grin. The two S Class Wizards were in the guildhall with Erza having just returned from an S Class mission, she had been regaling her fellow Fairy Tail friends about her exploits when Mirajane from the bar had made a snide comment
“I said you did a very good job Erza dear, although if it was me, I probably would have defeated that horde of demons a bit quicker than you” Mira repeated her comment
“Oh really?” Erza replied
“It’s not your fault though, after all we are all getting older right…” Mirajane smiled with her eyes closed in that irritating way that always got under Erza’s skin
While the red-haired and white-haired mages were technically friends they had also always been rivals since childhood, which had only made their need to one up the other intensify over the years. Throughout the night the comments and muttering between the two had gotten more and more prevalent, eventually coming to near blows with everyone having to physically restrain the two of them before they fought and most likely destroy the hall, it was only when Master Makarov arrived back and verbally chastised the two of them did they each back down
However, that night at the Fairy Hills dormitory as Mira prepared to go to sleep there was a knock on her door
“Erza?” she said as she opened it
“Mira” Erza replied “Look I’ve been thinking… this rivalry of ours… we need to find some way to settle it”
“Especially before we decimate the Guild hall…” Mira replied with a nod
“I have been trying to think of some way we could test ourselves to have a definite winner, not a magic based battle though as we would likely level the area”
“And I doubt the Magic Council would be happy, nor would the Master”
“We need something low key, but still difficult…” Erza replied as they began to think, then suddenly Erza got inspiration
“Hey wait a minute…”
The next morning
“Wait… what?” Natsu Dragneel said in confusion, he had been called to Mira’s room upon waking up and the ladies had explained their plan to him
“What part don’t you understand?” Erza asked
“The whole part about the… tickling?” he replied
“It’s simple, remember when I couldn’t move during that fight because of a magical paralysis and you took advantage of it to tickle me?”
“Yeah?”
“We want you to do that to both of us”
“Why?”
“Because tickling is an even playing field for a test to see who of us can endure the longest, there’s no pain or injury involved, and we can’t make any kind of defence to it with our magic”
“This is a joke, right?” Natsu replied unconvinced
“No, we are being totally honest” Mira replied, “And since we both know you Natsu we trust you to be a fair moderator”
“And you won’t beat me up afterwards?” he asked, still not entirely convinced
“We promise” they both replied
With that sorted and Natsu on board he went off to get some things he would need for the contest, while Mira and Erza went into the basement of Fairy Hills, with the casting of a soundproofing spell and some moving around of workout equipment they were able to prepare a set of make shift racks side by side
“Ok ladies, I’m here” Natsu said as he returned with a backpack and shut the door behind him, enacting a lock spell so they wouldn’t be interrupted “Now first thing first, I think you both need to change”
“Good point” Erza said as she stripped down to her white underwear, with Mira doing the same
“Sure you don’t want to back out?” Mira asked
“No chance, I’m going to win this!” she replied confidently
With them both stripped down Natsu took out two iron collars
“These are designed to block magic, they are similar to the ones the palace guards use in the dungeon” he explained as they took them and fixed the collars around their necks. Once they had been secured some runes on them glowed to show the sealing spell was now in place
“Ok,” he said “Let’s get you both ready” and he helped them each lay down on the racks, using ropes and padded cuffs to secure them both down spread-eagled and pulling the ropes to ensure they were taunt
“Comfortable?” he asked
“Yes” they both replied as the shifted about for emphasis to show they were trapped
“Ok then… let’s get started!”
Deciding for the sake of fairness to use a coin flip to choose who would go first Natsu flipped it and it landed on Tails… meaning Mirajane would be first
“Try not to break too quickly” Erza smirked, glad that this meant all she would have to do would be to outlast Mira to win!
“I’ll do my best” Mira smirked back, then looked to Natsu “Go on Natsu, do your worst!”
Natsu looked over her flawless body, most men (and even some women!) would sell their souls to be allowed to touch her or Erza and here he was with permission to play with them both! He still had to convince himself this was real as he looked through a bag of items he had prepared
“Ok let’s see what we have here…” he said before taking out a feather “Can’t beat the classics!” he added as he looked over Mira’s body to decide where to start
“Ok here we go…” he said as he moved the feather towards her left foot
“ghghffffmfmfff…” Mira giggled as her foot immediately flexed in response, she was really very ticklish, although was convinced she could outlast Erza as the soft plume continued stroking up and down her arch while she suppressed her giggles
“Come on Mira, coochie coochie coo…” Natsu said teasingly as he continued, watching her foot continue to flex
“GGHHFMFMFFHHH!!!!!!!” her laughter starting to get louder now but still refusing to give in
“Wanna be tough huh?” he said as he gripped her toes with his other hand and turned the feather around to start moving the quill end against her arch in a figure of eight shape
“HHAHAHAHAHAHAAAAA!!!!!!!!!!!” Mira shrieked as her body bucked around but the restraints held
“Looks like this worked” Natsu smirked as he continued, then switched back and used the plume end, stroking it up and down her arch as it began to twitch in response
“Looks like I got her going now!” Natsu grinned as he continued, then grabbed another feather to start using at her right foot
“HHAHAHAHAHA NAHAHAHTSSHHHSHAAAAUUUU!!!!!!!” Mira shrieked as the two plumes moved against her flailing soles
“Aw too much? Maybe you should quit already…” Erza said confidently
“HAHHAHAHAHAHAHA YOOOHHUUUU BEHEHEEEE QHHIIEEIEIEHEETTTT!!!!!!!” Mira giggled back as she tried kicking the feathers away
Natsu however decided to quickly change targets as he leaned in and trailed the feathers against her legs, inner thighs, then hips until they reached her navel
“HAHHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAAAAA NOHOHOHOOHOHOOHOOO!!!!!!!!” Mira shrieked as the two feathers lightly caressed her toned stomach
“Aw what’s wrong? Can’t get away?” he said menacingly as the feathers continued
“HAHAHHAHAHAHA GEEHHEEHEHTT THHEHEEEMM AWHAHAHAYYY!!!!!!!” she pleaded
“Nah I don’t think so…” he replied
“HHAAHHAHAA YOHOHUU JEEHHEHERKKK!!!!!!!”
“You’re the one who put me in charge, not my fault you chose a tickle contest!” he shrugged before turning the feathers around once more and unleashing the quills again
“NO NATSU DON’T YOU DHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHHRREEEE!!!!!!!!” Mira ordered then shrieked as the quills poked and dragged lightly around her navel, she shook about as much as possible, but it wasn’t enough to dissuade them
“Wow who would have guessed that an S Class wizard would have such a ticklish tummy!” he said in delight, before dropping the feathers, climbing onto the rack and unleashing his hands
“HHAAHHAHAHAHAA NOOHHOOHOHOHOO!!!!!! NAAHHATSSHSHUUU!!!!!!!” Mira screamed as his nimble fingers dug into her stomach before skittering up and down her sides as well, she thrashed around but like with the feather was unable to knock his probing digits away
“Coochie coochie coo Mira!” he grinned as he watched her laughing and struggling to escape “Bet you never thought this would be so hard!” he added as he kept going
Erza watched as Natsu continued tickling away with total abandon while Mira kept on laughing, but still not submitting
“How much longer is she going to keep going?” she thought, realising that every minute she didn’t submit meant she would have to likewise endure and then go beyond that amount of time in order to win! Mira meanwhile was still far from giving up despite laughing like crazy, but her resolve would quickly be tested when suddenly Natsu’s right index finger flicked against her belly button
“HHAHAHAHAHHAHAHAAAHAHAHAHA NOOHOHOHOHOHOHOOO!!!!!!!!!” she shrieked as she was caught off guard by this, her high-pitched wail shocking both Natsu and Erza, however Natsu quickly grinned wickedly
“Oh… did I find a tickle spot?”
“HAHAHA NOHOHOHO NANAHHTSSUU DOOHOHOHNNNTTT!!!!!!” she tried to say, then squealed as his index finger began skirting the edge of her belly button
“Oh? Wanna submit?”
“HAHAHHAHAHA NEHEHVVAAHAHHAAA!!!!!!!”
“Guess I’ll keep going then” he smirked as he continued, with Erza looking on and trying to hide her concern as she knew her own belly button was very ticklish as well!
Mira kept trying to knock his probing finger away with little success as it kept circling around her belly button
“HAHAHHAHA NAHAHATSSHHUUU!!!!!!!” she squealed, unable to stop laughing
“Wow, is this really how to beat an S class wizard? I mean I’m barely touching you and already your laughing hysterically…” he grinned
“HHAHAHAHAHAHAA STAHAHAHAHAPPP!!!!!” Mira cried though the giggles
“Nah I think I’m gonna do… THIS!” and with that he poked his index finger inside her belly button and lightly scratched about within
The reaction was instantaneous
“HHAHAHAHAHAHAHAAAA NOHOHOHOHOOHOOO GEHEHEHEHETT OOUHUHUHUUTT!!!!!!” Mira howled
“Oh? You want me to stop?”
“HAHAHHAHAHAHA YEEHHEHHSSSSS!!!!!!!!!”
“So you give up?”
“HAHAHAHAHAHAHA NOHOHOHOOOO!!!!!!!”
“Talk about mixed signals” he shrugged as his other hand skittered around her navel and side in conjunction with the index finger still tickling her belly button
Erza watched in amazement at how not only was Mira laughing hysterically from this, but also how sadistic Natsu was being, clearly enjoying his role as tickler
“Maybe this was a mistake…” she thought, her toes curling up in defence as she watched Natsu keep tickling away, a thought then hit her… if she and Mira were too stubborn to submit… how long would Natsu tickle them for? They hadn’t set a time limit for the contest!
However, at present Mira’s only thought was laughter and trying to not give up
“HAHHAHAHAHAHAA NAHAHAHTSHAHAHAHAUUU!!!!!!!!!”
“Yes?”
“IIHHTTTT TIIIHHCCKKLLEEESSSS!!!!!!!”
“That’s the idea!” he smirked before suddenly leaning his head in “Like so…” and he pressed his lips against her stomach
“WHAT ARE YOU GONNA DOHOHOHOHOOHOOOOO!!!!!!!!!” she asked fearfully, then shrieked as he blew a raspberry against the left side of her stomach, then another at the right side, the sensations sending shockwaves through her!
“HAHAHAHAHAHAH NOHOHOHOO!!!!!! NOHOHOHOTT TAHAHHAAHTT!!!!!!” she pleaded as he kept blowing more of them
“You didn’t say any kind of rules against them” he replied in-between blowing them, before she felt his lips pressing against her belly button
“NOHOHOHOOO!!! NAAHHTSSHHAAUUU!!!!!!! DOOHOHOHHAHAAHAHANNNTT!!!!!!!” she pleaded, then shrieked as a barrage of raspberries were launched one after the other upon her belly button, causing her back to arch, then she continued squealing as he poked out his tongue and moved it inside her belly button to lick around within
“HAHAHHAHAHAHAHAHAAA NOHOHOHOOOO!!!!!!!!” she wailed as Natsu slowly licked around inside her belly button and then around her navel
“How you holding up?” he asked when he stopped
“hahahhahaaa… nahahahtssuuu… chahanntt…” she tried to say, looking and feeling exhausted
“Wanna quit?” he asked, with Erza listening in
“hahahhaa…” she laughed back, before looking over to face Erza “nneheahhvahahhhaaa!!!!!!!!!” she replied back as she looked back to him, her face daring him to continue
“Suit yourself tough girl…” he grinned as he straddled her waist
Mira glared as she looked to him
“Do your worHAHAHAHHAHAHHHSSSTTTT!!!!!!!!!!” she began to say, only to shriek as his fingers dug into her underarms
“HHAHAHAHAHHAHAHAA OHOHOOHOHO NOOHOHOHOHOO NAHAHAHAAHTT THEHEHEHEHEEERRREEEE!!!!!!!” Mira screamed as she tried to move her arms and more importantly her underarms out of reach
“Trying to escape? Is it too much?” he grinned
“HHAHAHAHAHHAA NOHOHOHOOOO!!!!!!!!!!” Erza cried between laughter
“Sounds like it is!” he winked as his fingers skittered up and down the hollows of her underarms
Erza continued to watch as Mira wailed and laughed while trying unsuccessfully to evade Natsu’s fingers
“How long is she going to ensure this?” she thought aghast, worrying about how long she would then have to endure herself! Natsu meanwhile upped his game, as he grabbed the two feathers from before
“HHAAA NOHOHOOO!!!! NAAHHTSUUUHHUU!!!! DOHHNNAHAHANNTT!!!!!!!!!” Mira tried to plead, then shrieked as the plumes brushed against her underarms, the tips lightly flicking about
“HHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA OOHOHOHOO GAHAHAHAHHDDDDD!!!!!!!” Mira howled out loud as they continued moving against her skin
“Tickle tickle Mira!” Natsu smirked
“HHAHAHAHAHAHAHA MEEHHRCCCYYY!!!!!!!!!!” she pleaded
“Mercy? Ok, want me to leave your underarms?”
“HHAHAHAHAHA YEHEHEHEHHSSSS!!!!!!!!”
“Ok, if you insist…” he grinned, as he reached for the clasp at the front of her bra
“HAHHAHAHAHAHAHAH WHAHAHHAHATTTT???!!!!!!!” Mira shrieked in abject shock as her bra suddenly spilled open, allowing her impressively large chest to be bared
“WHAT ARE YOU DOING?!” Erza cried in shock at seeing this
“Get ready!” Natsu said wickedly as he inched the feathers closer
“HHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAA OHOHOOHOHOHOHOO NOHOHOHOOHOOOO!!!!!!!!” Mira let out a cry of panic as the feathers made contact, her back arching in response
“Wow trying to throw me off huh? Sorry Mira no such luck!” Natsu joked as he continued
“HHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAAA GEHEHEHETTT AHWWHAHAHAHAYYY!!!!!!!!!” Mira shrieked as she jostled about, her massive breasts bouncing around wildly but Natsu was able to keep pace and continue flicking the feathers against her
“HAHAHHAHAHAHAHA NAAHAHAHAHHATTSSHHUUHUUU!!!!!! STAHAHAHAPPP!!!!!!!” she pleaded
“Aw is it too much for the mighty S Class wizard?” he asked with a grin as he continued before adding “You know… I think you’re actually enjoying this!”
“HAHAHAHHAHAA WHAHAHAHHAATTTT?????!!!!!!!!!!” Mira gasped in shock
“Oh yes, look how hard these nipples have gone” he grinned, then suddenly leaned in and poked put his tongue
“HHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHHAAA OHOHOHOHOHOOH GAHAHAHAHAHDDDD!!!!!!!!” Mira screamed as his tongue flicked against the left nipple while the feather continued stroking against the right one
“Mmmm…” Natsu said aloud as he continued, while Erza watched in disbelief
“WHO KNEW NATSU COULD BE SUCH A SADIST!” she thought as he gleefully continued tormenting Mira
For almost twenty minutes Natsu relentlessly tormented Mira’s nipples and underarms with his fingers, tongue and the feathers as she pleaded, begged and shrieked for mercy that wouldn’t come until finally…
“How you feeling Mira?” he asked
“Hahahhahahahahaaa… chahahahannntt…hahahahaaa…” she babbled incoherently as she tried to breathe. Natsu watched then looked over to Erza, her eyes opening widely in a panic as a sadistic grin slowly appeared on his face
“Ok, let’s give you a break…” and he climbed off to move over to Erza
To be continued…
By MrObscura101
The Fairy Tail Guild hall…
“I’m sorry, would you like to repeat that?” Erza Scarlet said as her eyes narrowed
“Oh sorry, did I stutter?” Mirajane Strauss replied with a wry grin. The two S Class Wizards were in the guildhall with Erza having just returned from an S Class mission, she had been regaling her fellow Fairy Tail friends about her exploits when Mirajane from the bar had made a snide comment
“I said you did a very good job Erza dear, although if it was me, I probably would have defeated that horde of demons a bit quicker than you” Mira repeated her comment
“Oh really?” Erza replied
“It’s not your fault though, after all we are all getting older right…” Mirajane smiled with her eyes closed in that irritating way that always got under Erza’s skin
While the red-haired and white-haired mages were technically friends they had also always been rivals since childhood, which had only made their need to one up the other intensify over the years. Throughout the night the comments and muttering between the two had gotten more and more prevalent, eventually coming to near blows with everyone having to physically restrain the two of them before they fought and most likely destroy the hall, it was only when Master Makarov arrived back and verbally chastised the two of them did they each back down
However, that night at the Fairy Hills dormitory as Mira prepared to go to sleep there was a knock on her door
“Erza?” she said as she opened it
“Mira” Erza replied “Look I’ve been thinking… this rivalry of ours… we need to find some way to settle it”
“Especially before we decimate the Guild hall…” Mira replied with a nod
“I have been trying to think of some way we could test ourselves to have a definite winner, not a magic based battle though as we would likely level the area”
“And I doubt the Magic Council would be happy, nor would the Master”
“We need something low key, but still difficult…” Erza replied as they began to think, then suddenly Erza got inspiration
“Hey wait a minute…”
The next morning
“Wait… what?” Natsu Dragneel said in confusion, he had been called to Mira’s room upon waking up and the ladies had explained their plan to him
“What part don’t you understand?” Erza asked
“The whole part about the… tickling?” he replied
“It’s simple, remember when I couldn’t move during that fight because of a magical paralysis and you took advantage of it to tickle me?”
“Yeah?”
“We want you to do that to both of us”
“Why?”
“Because tickling is an even playing field for a test to see who of us can endure the longest, there’s no pain or injury involved, and we can’t make any kind of defence to it with our magic”
“This is a joke, right?” Natsu replied unconvinced
“No, we are being totally honest” Mira replied, “And since we both know you Natsu we trust you to be a fair moderator”
“And you won’t beat me up afterwards?” he asked, still not entirely convinced
“We promise” they both replied
With that sorted and Natsu on board he went off to get some things he would need for the contest, while Mira and Erza went into the basement of Fairy Hills, with the casting of a soundproofing spell and some moving around of workout equipment they were able to prepare a set of make shift racks side by side
“Ok ladies, I’m here” Natsu said as he returned with a backpack and shut the door behind him, enacting a lock spell so they wouldn’t be interrupted “Now first thing first, I think you both need to change”
“Good point” Erza said as she stripped down to her white underwear, with Mira doing the same
“Sure you don’t want to back out?” Mira asked
“No chance, I’m going to win this!” she replied confidently
With them both stripped down Natsu took out two iron collars
“These are designed to block magic, they are similar to the ones the palace guards use in the dungeon” he explained as they took them and fixed the collars around their necks. Once they had been secured some runes on them glowed to show the sealing spell was now in place
“Ok,” he said “Let’s get you both ready” and he helped them each lay down on the racks, using ropes and padded cuffs to secure them both down spread-eagled and pulling the ropes to ensure they were taunt
“Comfortable?” he asked
“Yes” they both replied as the shifted about for emphasis to show they were trapped
“Ok then… let’s get started!”
Deciding for the sake of fairness to use a coin flip to choose who would go first Natsu flipped it and it landed on Tails… meaning Mirajane would be first
“Try not to break too quickly” Erza smirked, glad that this meant all she would have to do would be to outlast Mira to win!
“I’ll do my best” Mira smirked back, then looked to Natsu “Go on Natsu, do your worst!”
Natsu looked over her flawless body, most men (and even some women!) would sell their souls to be allowed to touch her or Erza and here he was with permission to play with them both! He still had to convince himself this was real as he looked through a bag of items he had prepared
“Ok let’s see what we have here…” he said before taking out a feather “Can’t beat the classics!” he added as he looked over Mira’s body to decide where to start
“Ok here we go…” he said as he moved the feather towards her left foot
“ghghffffmfmfff…” Mira giggled as her foot immediately flexed in response, she was really very ticklish, although was convinced she could outlast Erza as the soft plume continued stroking up and down her arch while she suppressed her giggles
“Come on Mira, coochie coochie coo…” Natsu said teasingly as he continued, watching her foot continue to flex
“GGHHFMFMFFHHH!!!!!!!” her laughter starting to get louder now but still refusing to give in
“Wanna be tough huh?” he said as he gripped her toes with his other hand and turned the feather around to start moving the quill end against her arch in a figure of eight shape
“HHAHAHAHAHAHAAAAA!!!!!!!!!!!” Mira shrieked as her body bucked around but the restraints held
“Looks like this worked” Natsu smirked as he continued, then switched back and used the plume end, stroking it up and down her arch as it began to twitch in response
“Looks like I got her going now!” Natsu grinned as he continued, then grabbed another feather to start using at her right foot
“HHAHAHAHAHA NAHAHAHTSSHHHSHAAAAUUUU!!!!!!!” Mira shrieked as the two plumes moved against her flailing soles
“Aw too much? Maybe you should quit already…” Erza said confidently
“HAHHAHAHAHAHAHA YOOOHHUUUU BEHEHEEEE QHHIIEEIEIEHEETTTT!!!!!!!” Mira giggled back as she tried kicking the feathers away
Natsu however decided to quickly change targets as he leaned in and trailed the feathers against her legs, inner thighs, then hips until they reached her navel
“HAHHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAAAAA NOHOHOHOOHOHOOHOOO!!!!!!!!” Mira shrieked as the two feathers lightly caressed her toned stomach
“Aw what’s wrong? Can’t get away?” he said menacingly as the feathers continued
“HAHAHHAHAHAHA GEEHHEEHEHTT THHEHEEEMM AWHAHAHAYYY!!!!!!!” she pleaded
“Nah I don’t think so…” he replied
“HHAAHHAHAA YOHOHUU JEEHHEHERKKK!!!!!!!”
“You’re the one who put me in charge, not my fault you chose a tickle contest!” he shrugged before turning the feathers around once more and unleashing the quills again
“NO NATSU DON’T YOU DHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHHRREEEE!!!!!!!!” Mira ordered then shrieked as the quills poked and dragged lightly around her navel, she shook about as much as possible, but it wasn’t enough to dissuade them
“Wow who would have guessed that an S Class wizard would have such a ticklish tummy!” he said in delight, before dropping the feathers, climbing onto the rack and unleashing his hands
“HHAAHHAHAHAHAA NOOHHOOHOHOHOO!!!!!! NAAHHATSSHSHUUU!!!!!!!” Mira screamed as his nimble fingers dug into her stomach before skittering up and down her sides as well, she thrashed around but like with the feather was unable to knock his probing digits away
“Coochie coochie coo Mira!” he grinned as he watched her laughing and struggling to escape “Bet you never thought this would be so hard!” he added as he kept going
Erza watched as Natsu continued tickling away with total abandon while Mira kept on laughing, but still not submitting
“How much longer is she going to keep going?” she thought, realising that every minute she didn’t submit meant she would have to likewise endure and then go beyond that amount of time in order to win! Mira meanwhile was still far from giving up despite laughing like crazy, but her resolve would quickly be tested when suddenly Natsu’s right index finger flicked against her belly button
“HHAHAHAHAHHAHAHAAAHAHAHAHA NOOHOHOHOHOHOHOOO!!!!!!!!!” she shrieked as she was caught off guard by this, her high-pitched wail shocking both Natsu and Erza, however Natsu quickly grinned wickedly
“Oh… did I find a tickle spot?”
“HAHAHA NOHOHOHO NANAHHTSSUU DOOHOHOHNNNTTT!!!!!!” she tried to say, then squealed as his index finger began skirting the edge of her belly button
“Oh? Wanna submit?”
“HAHAHHAHAHA NEHEHVVAAHAHHAAA!!!!!!!”
“Guess I’ll keep going then” he smirked as he continued, with Erza looking on and trying to hide her concern as she knew her own belly button was very ticklish as well!
Mira kept trying to knock his probing finger away with little success as it kept circling around her belly button
“HAHAHHAHA NAHAHATSSHHUUU!!!!!!!” she squealed, unable to stop laughing
“Wow, is this really how to beat an S class wizard? I mean I’m barely touching you and already your laughing hysterically…” he grinned
“HHAHAHAHAHAHAA STAHAHAHAHAPPP!!!!!” Mira cried though the giggles
“Nah I think I’m gonna do… THIS!” and with that he poked his index finger inside her belly button and lightly scratched about within
The reaction was instantaneous
“HHAHAHAHAHAHAHAAAA NOHOHOHOHOOHOOO GEHEHEHEHETT OOUHUHUHUUTT!!!!!!” Mira howled
“Oh? You want me to stop?”
“HAHAHHAHAHAHA YEEHHEHHSSSSS!!!!!!!!!”
“So you give up?”
“HAHAHAHAHAHAHA NOHOHOHOOOO!!!!!!!”
“Talk about mixed signals” he shrugged as his other hand skittered around her navel and side in conjunction with the index finger still tickling her belly button
Erza watched in amazement at how not only was Mira laughing hysterically from this, but also how sadistic Natsu was being, clearly enjoying his role as tickler
“Maybe this was a mistake…” she thought, her toes curling up in defence as she watched Natsu keep tickling away, a thought then hit her… if she and Mira were too stubborn to submit… how long would Natsu tickle them for? They hadn’t set a time limit for the contest!
However, at present Mira’s only thought was laughter and trying to not give up
“HAHHAHAHAHAHAA NAHAHAHTSHAHAHAHAUUU!!!!!!!!!”
“Yes?”
“IIHHTTTT TIIIHHCCKKLLEEESSSS!!!!!!!”
“That’s the idea!” he smirked before suddenly leaning his head in “Like so…” and he pressed his lips against her stomach
“WHAT ARE YOU GONNA DOHOHOHOHOOHOOOOO!!!!!!!!!” she asked fearfully, then shrieked as he blew a raspberry against the left side of her stomach, then another at the right side, the sensations sending shockwaves through her!
“HAHAHAHAHAHAH NOHOHOHOO!!!!!! NOHOHOHOTT TAHAHHAAHTT!!!!!!” she pleaded as he kept blowing more of them
“You didn’t say any kind of rules against them” he replied in-between blowing them, before she felt his lips pressing against her belly button
“NOHOHOHOOO!!! NAAHHTSSHHAAUUU!!!!!!! DOOHOHOHHAHAAHAHANNNTT!!!!!!!” she pleaded, then shrieked as a barrage of raspberries were launched one after the other upon her belly button, causing her back to arch, then she continued squealing as he poked out his tongue and moved it inside her belly button to lick around within
“HAHAHHAHAHAHAHAHAAA NOHOHOHOOOO!!!!!!!!” she wailed as Natsu slowly licked around inside her belly button and then around her navel
“How you holding up?” he asked when he stopped
“hahahhahaaa… nahahahtssuuu… chahanntt…” she tried to say, looking and feeling exhausted
“Wanna quit?” he asked, with Erza listening in
“hahahhaa…” she laughed back, before looking over to face Erza “nneheahhvahahhhaaa!!!!!!!!!” she replied back as she looked back to him, her face daring him to continue
“Suit yourself tough girl…” he grinned as he straddled her waist
Mira glared as she looked to him
“Do your worHAHAHAHHAHAHHHSSSTTTT!!!!!!!!!!” she began to say, only to shriek as his fingers dug into her underarms
“HHAHAHAHAHHAHAHAA OHOHOOHOHO NOOHOHOHOHOO NAHAHAHAAHTT THEHEHEHEHEEERRREEEE!!!!!!!” Mira screamed as she tried to move her arms and more importantly her underarms out of reach
“Trying to escape? Is it too much?” he grinned
“HHAHAHAHAHHAA NOHOHOHOOOO!!!!!!!!!!” Erza cried between laughter
“Sounds like it is!” he winked as his fingers skittered up and down the hollows of her underarms
Erza continued to watch as Mira wailed and laughed while trying unsuccessfully to evade Natsu’s fingers
“How long is she going to ensure this?” she thought aghast, worrying about how long she would then have to endure herself! Natsu meanwhile upped his game, as he grabbed the two feathers from before
“HHAAA NOHOHOOO!!!! NAAHHTSUUUHHUU!!!! DOHHNNAHAHANNTT!!!!!!!!!” Mira tried to plead, then shrieked as the plumes brushed against her underarms, the tips lightly flicking about
“HHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA OOHOHOHOO GAHAHAHAHHDDDDD!!!!!!!” Mira howled out loud as they continued moving against her skin
“Tickle tickle Mira!” Natsu smirked
“HHAHAHAHAHAHAHA MEEHHRCCCYYY!!!!!!!!!!” she pleaded
“Mercy? Ok, want me to leave your underarms?”
“HHAHAHAHAHA YEHEHEHEHHSSSS!!!!!!!!”
“Ok, if you insist…” he grinned, as he reached for the clasp at the front of her bra
“HAHHAHAHAHAHAHAH WHAHAHHAHATTTT???!!!!!!!” Mira shrieked in abject shock as her bra suddenly spilled open, allowing her impressively large chest to be bared
“WHAT ARE YOU DOING?!” Erza cried in shock at seeing this
“Get ready!” Natsu said wickedly as he inched the feathers closer
“HHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAA OHOHOOHOHOHOHOO NOHOHOHOOHOOOO!!!!!!!!” Mira let out a cry of panic as the feathers made contact, her back arching in response
“Wow trying to throw me off huh? Sorry Mira no such luck!” Natsu joked as he continued
“HHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAAA GEHEHEHETTT AHWWHAHAHAHAYYY!!!!!!!!!” Mira shrieked as she jostled about, her massive breasts bouncing around wildly but Natsu was able to keep pace and continue flicking the feathers against her
“HAHAHHAHAHAHAHA NAAHAHAHAHHATTSSHHUUHUUU!!!!!! STAHAHAHAPPP!!!!!!!” she pleaded
“Aw is it too much for the mighty S Class wizard?” he asked with a grin as he continued before adding “You know… I think you’re actually enjoying this!”
“HAHAHAHHAHAA WHAHAHAHHAATTTT?????!!!!!!!!!!” Mira gasped in shock
“Oh yes, look how hard these nipples have gone” he grinned, then suddenly leaned in and poked put his tongue
“HHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHHAAA OHOHOHOHOHOOH GAHAHAHAHAHDDDD!!!!!!!!” Mira screamed as his tongue flicked against the left nipple while the feather continued stroking against the right one
“Mmmm…” Natsu said aloud as he continued, while Erza watched in disbelief
“WHO KNEW NATSU COULD BE SUCH A SADIST!” she thought as he gleefully continued tormenting Mira
For almost twenty minutes Natsu relentlessly tormented Mira’s nipples and underarms with his fingers, tongue and the feathers as she pleaded, begged and shrieked for mercy that wouldn’t come until finally…
“How you feeling Mira?” he asked
“Hahahhahahahahaaa… chahahahannntt…hahahahaaa…” she babbled incoherently as she tried to breathe. Natsu watched then looked over to Erza, her eyes opening widely in a panic as a sadistic grin slowly appeared on his face
“Ok, let’s give you a break…” and he climbed off to move over to Erza
To be continued…
