Some1, from reading your post, it sounds to me like you have a tickling fetish, and a semi foot fetish.
The fact that you notice feet, and want them to be ticklish shows that you have an interest in feet, and a definite tickle fetish. However, the idea that you may not find feet that arent ticklish not attractive, says to me that your tickle fetish is, in my opinion, stronger than your foot fetish.
For me, I had the opposite. I have had a female foot fetish since I can remember. Even when I was little, if I saw a pretty bare foot, I loved it. Through the years, the foot fetish became stronger, while the tickle fetish developed from reading articles about tickling in sex mags, and through having my pen pal Don Fraser, who liked both tickling, and female feet like I do, from 1997 to 2002. It was once I joined this site, that I really realized how strong both fetishes are for me.
Nowadays, if I see a woman I find attractive on TV, or in real life, and dont know her ticklish status, because we cant obviously know the status of every woman we find attractive, three things run through my mind: If she's ticklish and where, whether her feet are ticklish, and what her tickling experiences have been in life. To me, it would be first choice for me to have a woman in my life with mega ticklish feet who is at least okay with tickling, and someone who is agreeable to having her feet kissed, toes sucked, and such, so that I could engage in both fetishes. As for whether I will ever find such a woman, time will tell.
So, from what you're told me, I think you probably have a strong tickle fetish, and a mild foot fetish. Pretty cool. To me, you're just like thousands of others here. More power to you, my friend! 😎
Mitch