I'm not sure what golfer is arguing above, so I’ll try and hit all the possibilities that I can see.
If it's that we are trying to hide the theater from users, we are not. It's right
here. Have a blast, it's owner has built a great site, and has managed to find a way to handle the bandwidth of hosting a mighty pile of media, My hat is off to him on that, as I shudder at the expense. It’s my hope that he can manage to continue doing it for a very long time. It’s a huge asset to our community.
If he's arguing that you can easily find copyrighted material there (or links to it), I'm sure you can, policing a site like his, or this one, is a big job, and we tend to rely upon users and copyright holders to point out violations to us. If no one does, then such may (and do) go unnoticed. I won’t even try to say that we could view every site that is linked here. There is simply too much to look at it all. It’s not possible.
But, just because it does exist for these reasons, does not indicate that we condone it. (I can't speak for the Theater, but from conversations I wager his thoughts are similar)
I can understand why golfer (and probably the majority of our users) may dislike our policy, as it makes it harder for him (them) to find free material that he (they) would enjoy.
But what I always have a hard time understanding is how anyone can honestly justify the ‘rightness’ of supporting the theft of someone’s work. I always like to assume they just don’t understand the costs to the creator when it happens, and it’s not that they are too self involved in oafishly gobbling pleasure from a free trough that they never think about it. I’ve yet to see an argument that holds water in justifying it.
Golfers statement, is, in my eyes, equivalent as to saying “Hey, that 7-11 store down the street has a real lax clerk on in afternoons, if you help yourself to stuff he’ll never notice.”
On second thought, perhaps a better analogy would be “Hey I know someone who scored a ton of stuff from the 7-11, and is just giving it away! He’s on the corner of 6th and Eagle.” Yes that fits much better.
Is it wrong to point others at the opportunity to enjoy stolen goods? I’ll leave the moral side of the question to each user, as it is indeed an individual one. We feel it is wrong, and policy here on this forum follows that opinion. It's not rhetoric, it's an actual responsibility that we feel we owe to the media creators, and that we are serious about.
Myriads