As Americans nation-wide struggle to cope with feelings of shock, grief and anger at last Wednesday's unprovoked mass-shooting in a Colorado movie theatre which left 12 people dead and dozens injured, many are starting to question whether our massive outpouring of public support and charitable donations to an elderly bus monitor may have been, in retrospect, a bit of an overreaction.
"I can't believe it," said Sandra Brunholm of Stokey, Conneticut. "There were children there, and he just gunned them down the same as everyone else. What kind of sick psychopathic monster could do a thing like that?" Pausing to collect herself, she continued, "What were we all talking about before this happened? Some fat lady on a bus? Jesus, I feel sick."
Others echoed these sentiments. "Yes, I gave money," says Larry Chisholm of Los Angeles, CA. "I guess she just kind of reminded me of my grandmother, and when I saw that video of those kids being mean to her, my heart just went out and I wanted to do something. So I gave her $50."
"Did you know four different men died saving their girlfriends' lives that night? Four. It's amazing. Frankly, now I kind of wish I had saved that $50 for one of them."
According to experts, feelings of guilt, rage, and puzzlement are all common in the wake of a tragedy, as well as a tendency to re-evaluate what constitutes a 'tragedy' in the first place.
"Most Americans never have to deal with any genuine hardship in their day-to-day lives," says Dr. Alfonso Schmitt of Arizona State University. "In a complacent setting, one minor act of bullying on a public school bus can grab everybody's attention and become the focus of moral outrage that has no other legitimate target."
"Then, something like this happens, and we all feel like morons."
In his address to the nation, President Obama pledged a level of national support for the victims and their families that will match, if not outdo, the support we showed the bullied bus monitor.
"My experts are working around the clock," said President Obama in an address on Tuesday. "The hearts of all Americans are with the victims of this terrible crime, and I pledge we will not rest until we come up with a dollar amount, or some kind of stupefyingly huge gesture, that will save us all from looking like hypocrites when these two reactions are examined side by side."