The fact is this. Yes, of course in "real life", people can be rude as hell. We all encounter it. What I'm about to say has been said before. Mimi saying it comes to mind, but, I'm sure that through the history of this site, Jeff, Myriads, and other mods and admins have said what I am about to as well.
Mods, for the record, not to paraphrase, or "parrot" what any of you have said in the past. This is a private site. The "rules", as the poster who took issue with them, called them, are drawn up by Jeff, Myriads, and the mods and admins. They decide what is permitted, and what isn't. The TMF is their internet home, and, essentially, every one of us are their guests. While all the good members consider ourselves welcomed guests in their home at any time, and truly consider it our own home, if we screw with their rules that they have set up, they have the right to take action, talk to us, warn us of a ban, or, if it is serious or consistent enough rude behavior, they can toss us out. Myriads and Jeff have said this: They dont like to throw around bans, because it isnt positive for anyone, them, or us. However, if people are going to be rude on a consistent basis, they can toss us. It is their right, whether we like it, or not.
For me, "The Golden Rule" does work. I much prefer a site where people are attempting to be civil to each other, and post positive things, rather then everyone being all "Oh, you suck, and you suck, etc". The Golden Rule is also subject to interpretation. I've had times when I've had things said to me, that I've asked the mods to take a look at. Sometimes, they will remove it. Others, they have said to me:" Sharp, and maybe not the best, but not warranting us to remove it, or warn whoever put it up". I may have been disappointed at their call on a particular issue, but I accepted it, and moved on. I looked at the greater picture. If I wanted to be here, I needed to follow the Golden Rules, and accept the mods judgement calls, whether I felt those calls were right, or wrong, on a particular issue, because, unless I dont want to be here anymore, being here, and privately disagreeing with things that might have happened, is better than not being here at all.
To me, the Golden Rule is a good thing. I would much prefer a site where people are mandated to be civil. Can you imagine what this site would look like, if people who might have disliked each other for whatever reason, carried their flame wars on to the board, and we had, cluttering the board. "Oh, Andy Smith sucks. Or :Susan Jones is a jerk". (Only examples of course, and if there are, in fact, members here, whose real names are Andy Smith, and/ or Susan Jones, my apologies, I was just using such as an example) People wouldnt want to be here, and read all that crap. It is much better to have debate, or, if there is disagreement, to do so in a civil manner.
Mitch