Which QB would you take #1 Overall? Winston or Mariota

[BBGuy5240]

So the NFL Draft is coming up. And it's pretty clear that a QB will be taken #1 Overall by Tampa Bay. The question is, which one will they take.

Winston would probably fit in a Traditional Passing Offense better than Mariota, but Winstons Maturity and what he does Off The Field raises questions. And throwing a ton of Money at him probably won't help.

With Mariota, he's had no Off The Field issues, but the question with him is, would he fit in a Traditional Passing Offense at all?

Because he's used to running that Oregon Offense. And unless the Philadelphia Eagles make a move, chances are he's gonna have to completely change his Game. I mean maybe he could adjust to it, but would you take that chance with the #1 Overall Pick.

I honestly don't know what I would do.

 

[Sodahead]

They're both good but I'd go with Mariota. I know it sounds cliche, but I just think Winston, while more talented overall, is too much of a wild card off the field. I know everyone does at least something stupid when they are young, but I feel like Winston lacks self control away from football and could land in series trouble.

If you base it purely on talent, I'd go with Winston though.

 

[TicklishBlackGuy]

Really want Mariota on the Bears squad. Winston is a good QB too, and there are a few other
good QB's out there.

 

[ManWithNoHat]

I think Mariotta might be alright in the NFL. If he's on the right team, he can do well.
Me personally, I don't want any part of Jameis Winston... not one bit. Especially not in Cleveland, I'd even rather have Manziel that Winston... which is truly saying something.