GiggleTales
Registered User
- Joined
- Dec 12, 2024
- Messages
- 44
- Points
- 33
FOR COMMISSIONS, DM ON DEVIANTART: https://www.deviantart.com/natorlstudio
The Saturday morning class let out in a wash of sweat and borrowed playlists. Kristen lingered on her mat a minute longer than the women who had carpool deadlines. Thirty-six, three kids, a former classroom still living in the way she stacked her water bottle and folded the towel into a neat rectangle. From the front she looked like what she was on paper: suburban mom, athletic in a practical way, hair in a ponytail that had started neat and ended damp. The other version of her — the one with the following she never mentioned at pickup — was in her feet.
She had kicked the sneakers off halfway through cooldown. Habit. Her soles liked the mat better than the shoes after forty minutes of work. Long toes. High, pronounced arches that showed when she pointed. Skin still pink from the room. She sat with one leg folded and the other extended, folded forward over the long leg, and reached for the toes the way the instructor had said to, except the instructor had already left and Kristen was not stretching for form anymore. She was stretching because it felt good and because, in the back of her mind, she knew what her feet looked like when she did this.
She felt the look before she placed it.
Not on her face. Not on the black capris or the faded rec-league shirt. On her feet. Mid-room, near the free weights that bordered the studio glass, a man she had seen here for months was not putting plates away. He was standing with a towel around his neck, good-looking in the uncomplicated way some men were after a lift — dark skin, close-cut hair, the kind of build that made the gym lighting do him favors — and his eyes were on her bare soles.
Kristen’s first instinct, the mom instinct, was to tuck them under her thighs and laugh it off at herself. She did not do that.
She flexed instead. Slow. The arch of the extended foot lifted off the mat and settled. Her toes spread and closed. She told herself she was just finishing the stretch. She knew she was not just finishing the stretch. The private little thrill she got when strangers online commented on a photo of her painted toes was the same heat, only this one had a body attached to it and a gym full of people who were not looking.
He noticed the flex. She saw it in the way his mouth moved, not quite a smile. He did not walk over. He did not pretend he had been looking at the clock. He watched her feet the way people watched a screen they had not meant to stop on.
Kristen switched legs.
The other foot came out, same long toes, same high arch, a faint line of mat-texture on the heel. She folded over it and stayed there longer than the stretch required. Sweat cooled at her hairline. Somewhere a weight stack clacked. A woman laughed by the water fountain. Kristen’s world had narrowed to the mat, the open sole, and the man who had not looked away.
She had joked with Chris about this.
Not this exact man. The idea of him. Chris had had an interest for years in sharing her feet with another foot lover. They had talked about it in bed the way some couples talked about vacations they would never book. She had said, half into the pillow, that if it ever happened she would want it to be a good-looking Black guy. She had said it like a joke that was not entirely a joke. Chris had gone quiet in the good way. After that the jokes had edges. After that she had started leaving her shoes off more often when she stretched at home where he could see.
The gym was not home.
She sat up, rolled her ankles, and let both feet rest on the mat with the soles half-turned toward the weights. An invitation she could still deny if anyone asked. He took one step closer. Not into her space. Into a better angle. She could see he was looking at the arches now, at the way the skin creased when she pointed and flexed. Her feet were notoriously ticklish. Chris knew that in the particular, lived-in way a husband of years knew it. This man did not know it yet. He was only looking. The looking was already doing something to her that she would have to take home and decide whether to confess.
She picked up the towel and dragged it once over each sole, slow enough to be drying them, slow enough to be showing them. Then she stood, still barefoot, and walked to her bag at the edge of the studio. The floor was cool. Her toes spread on it. She did not put the sneakers on immediately. She sat on the bench, bag open, water in her hand, and left her feet in the aisle where the path from the weights to the door had to pass.
He passed.
He did not speak. His eyes dropped to her feet as he went by, held, lifted to her face for half a second — not rude, not shy — and then he was gone toward the locker hallway. Kristen sat on the bench with her heart going in a rhythm that had nothing to do with the class. She put the sneakers on without socks, the way she sometimes did when she wanted to feel the canvas on still-warm skin, and she drove home with the radio lower than usual.
The house was the controlled chaos she always came back to. Someone’s shin guard in the hall. A recital notice on the fridge. Chris at the counter with coffee that had gone cold because the morning had gotten away from him too. The kids were at a birthday party until three. The quiet was a rare square of Saturday they usually spent catching up on nothing.
He looked at her gym bag, at her still-damp hair, at the fact that she had not launched into the class recap she usually launched into.
“Good one?” he asked.
“Mm.” She dropped the bag and leaned on the other side of the counter. Her sneakers were already off again. Habit. Her bare feet on their kitchen tile. Long toes. The arches he liked to look at when he thought she was not paying attention. “There was a guy.”
Chris’s coffee mug stopped halfway.
She told it without dressing it up. The cooldown. The sneakers off. The stretch that had gone on too long. The man from the weights who had been coming to the same gym for months. Good-looking. Black. Watching her feet, not her face. The flex she had given him on purpose. The towel on the soles. The walk to the bag with her shoes still off. The pass in the aisle where he had looked down and then at her and said nothing.
Chris listened the way he listened when the jokes stopped being jokes. His eyes had gone to her feet on the tile without him seeming to decide to look. She flexed them once, the same slow lift of the arch she had given the man on the mat, and watched her husband’s throat work.
“You didn’t pull them in,” he said. Not a question.
“No.”
“Did you want him to come over?”
Kristen breathed out through her nose. The wholesome version of her — dance recitals, birthday bags, the woman in the family photographs — would have said of course not. The other version, the one who posted her feet for strangers and owned a drawer of things the PTA did not need to know about, the one who had said a good-looking Black guy into a pillow, did not rush to close it.
“I wanted him to keep looking,” she said. “I don’t know if I wanted him to come over. In the gym? With people? I don’t know. I liked that he didn’t pretend he wasn’t doing it.”
Chris set the mug down. He came around the counter. He did not grab her. He crouched, which he did sometimes when the interest in him got specific, and he looked at her feet the way the man at the gym had looked at them, except Chris had years of knowing how ticklish they were and he did not touch them yet.
“Long toes,” he said, almost to himself. “Those arches. He got a show.”
“He got a show I let him have.”
“Would you let him have more?”
There it was. The vacation they had never booked, sitting on their kitchen tile between a shin guard and cold coffee. Kristen’s face went warm. She was thirty-six and a mother of three and she could feel the mischievous streak in her like a second pulse.
“I don’t know him,” she said. “I know his face. That’s different than a stranger from a parking lot. That’s why it didn’t feel as crazy.” She paused. “You still want the fishing thing.”
Chris had wanted the fishing thing for a year. Her in a busy mall lot, book in her lap, bare feet out the window, as if she were just airing them after errands. A net she pretended not to be holding. He had described it often enough that she could see the lot, the minivan two spaces over, the way her soles would look against painted metal.
“Today,” he said. “After this. Kids aren’t back until three. You already did the gym. You’re already barefoot in your head. Go sit in the lot and read. If nobody comes, nobody comes. If somebody does—”
“If it’s him,” she said.
They both heard it.
Chris looked up from her feet. The interest in his face was not anger. It was the same heat she had felt on the mat when she had not tucked her soles away.
“If it’s him,” he said, “you don’t have to do anything you don’t want. You can laugh and pull them in. Or you can let him find out they’re ticklish. You’ve said they are. I’ve told you they are. He doesn’t know yet.”
Kristen laughed once, short, the goofy edge of her that sat next to the polished one. “You’re really doing this. You’re sending your wife to dangle her feet out a car window because a man at 24 Hour looked at them.”
“I’m asking,” Chris said. “You’ve been posting them for people you’ll never meet. This is one you’ll recognize if he walks up. You said that made it more comfortable. So go see if he shops at the same mall we do on Saturdays. Or if he doesn’t, go see what it feels like to wait.”
She looked down at her own feet. The mat-texture had faded. The arches were still there, the long toes, the skin that went helpless if the right fingers found the center. Notoriously ticklish. A secret that was not a secret in this house and would not stay a secret if she left the window down.
“I’ll take a book,” she said.
“Take the one you never finish. You’ll want something to look at that isn’t your own toes.”
She almost told him the rest: that when the man had passed her on the bench she had thought about his hands. That she had thought about whether a foot lover from the gym would be gentle or whether he would go straight for the arches the way Chris did when he stopped being careful. That the contrast — recital mom, birthday-party mom, the woman with a pink toy in the nightstand she did not mention at lunch — was part of why the looking had landed so hard. She did not say all of that. She said:
“If he comes up to the car, I’m texting you.”
“Good.”
“If I let him touch them, I’m texting you that too.”
Chris’s mouth moved. He stood. He kissed her hair, gym-damp, and his hand found her waist and not her feet, which somehow made the feet louder.
“Go fishing,” he said.
Kristen put the sneakers back on without socks. She took the paperback from the basket under the side table, the one with the bent page from three weeks ago. She took her keys. At the door she stopped and looked back. Chris was still by the counter. He was looking at the place on the tile where her bare feet had been.
“He was really looking,” she said. “Not a glance. Looking.”
“I know.”
“I liked it.”
“I know that too.”
She left.
The Saturday light on the driveway was ordinary. A neighbor waved. A sprinkler ticked. Kristen started the car and felt her own pulse in the arches of her feet against the pedals, and she drove toward the mall lot with the book on the passenger seat and the gym still on her skin, and the man from the weights still standing in the back of her mind with a towel around his neck and his eyes on her soles.
She did not know if he would be there.
She knew she was going to roll the window down anyway.
She knew that if a shadow fell across her bare feet while she pretended to read, she would have to decide, in a parking lot in the middle of a wholesome Saturday, whether the woman in the family photographs was going to pull her toes in — or flex them again, slow, the way she had on the mat, and see what a man who already liked looking would do when he was allowed to touch.
The mall lot on Saturday at noon was a sea of hatchbacks and sunstruck windshields. Kristen parked at the far edge, two rows back from the main doors, where the walking traffic thinned but did not die. A family dragged a stroller past her bumper. Someone’s bagged pretzel threw cinnamon into the air. She killed the engine, sat with both hands on the wheel, and laughed once at herself, quiet, because the whole thing was ridiculous and she was doing it anyway.
Book. Window. Feet.
She had promised Chris.
The paperback bent open to the same dog-eared page she had not finished in three weeks. She dropped the driver’s seat back a notch, rolled the window down, and for a moment she only sat there with her sneakers still on, a suburban mom in a rec-league shirt with a gym ponytail going frizzy, looking like she had pulled over to wait for a kid who was still in the food court. Then she toed the sneakers off, peeled the invisible leftover of the class off her soles with her thumb, and lifted both feet through the open window.
The metal of the door was warm. Her heels hooked the frame. Her long toes hung in the open air. The arches — high, obvious, the ones the man at the gym had watched like a screen — faced the lane.
She felt immediately, vividly on display.
Not the clean kind of display she got from a photo she could crop and caption. This was her actual Saturday attached to her actual car in an actual lot where a woman from preschool could walk by with a slushie. Kristen opened the book and stared at a paragraph she did not read. A breeze found the damp crease of her left arch and she almost pulled in. She did not pull in. She pointed her toes once, slow, the same flex she had given him on the mat, and the thrill that went up her legs had nothing to do with literature.
She texted Chris with the book still open on her stomach.
Up. Far lot. Feeling like an idiot.
The reply came fast.
Good. Leave them out. Tell me if anyone stops.
She set the phone face-down on the console and went back to pretending to read. A man with a Home Depot bucket crossed two rows over and did not look. A teenager on a phone did not look. A woman in yoga pants glanced at the hanging feet, made the small face people made at odd parking-lot behavior, and kept walking. Kristen’s ears were hot. The mischievous streak that lived under the recital photos liked the heat. The mom streak wanted the sneakers back on.
Five minutes.
Eight.
Her soles were warming in the sun. She could feel the skin of the arches tightening the way it did on the pool deck in July. She rolled her ankles. The long toes spread and closed. She thought about the man from the weights — towel, dark skin, the look that had not been a glance — and she thought about Chris at the kitchen counter asking whether she had wanted him to come over. She still did not have a clean answer. She had an answer that lived in her feet, which were still out the window.
A shadow cut the sun on her soles.
She did not look up at once. She finished the sentence she was not reading. Then she lifted her eyes over the paperback.
It was him.
Same man. Same build. Street clothes now, not gym gear — dark shirt, jeans — but the face from the studio glass was unmistakable. He had stopped in the lane a yard from her door, not blocking it, close enough that her hanging feet were pointed more or less at his belt. He looked at them first. Then at her. Then at the book, as if he were checking whether the whole picture was what it appeared to be.
Kristen’s laugh came out too quick.
“Oh my God. You’re from the gym.”
“Yeah.” His voice was lower than she had built in her head. Not unkind. Amused in a way that made her want to tuck her toes in and also not. “You were on the mat after class. Shoes off.”
“That was stretching.”
“Uh-huh.”
He did not move closer yet. He let the feet hang in the space between them. Kristen was suddenly, sharply aware of every detail he could see: the length of her toes, the height of the arches, the faint pink left from the studio floor, a shiny line of sun-sweat in the center of the left sole. She kept the book up like a shield that was doing nothing.
“This is going to sound worse than the stretching,” she said. “My husband has this thing. Fishing. I sit here with a book and… this. It’s stupid.”
“Doesn’t look stupid from here.”
He said it looking at her soles, not her face. The same look from the gym, only now there was no glass and no weight rack to pretend about. Kristen’s pulse sat in the arches. She almost texted Chris with one hand and did not, because she would have to take her eyes off the man to do it.
“You’re the one who was watching,” she said.
“You flexed.”
She had. She could not pretend she had not. The admission sat in the warm air with the pretzel smell and a cart rattling somewhere behind him.
“I didn’t think you’d be at the mall.”
“I wasn’t, until I was.” He tipped his chin at her feet. “You leaving those out for anybody, or was the gym a specific invitation?”
Kristen’s mouth went dry. The family-photograph version of her had a speech about boundaries and jokes and how this was just airing out after errands. The other version — the one with the online following and the nightstand drawer and the pillow confession about a good-looking Black guy — heard the question and did not pull her feet in.
“Anybody was the official story,” she said. “The gym is why I didn’t put the sneakers back on when I saw you walking over.”
His mouth moved. Almost a smile. He stepped in half a pace, still not touching, close enough now that if she pointed her toes she would brush denim.
“Can I?”
Two words. Kristen’s laugh this time was smaller, helpless at the edges. She glanced at the lot. A couple with bags was a row away, not looking. A car door slammed. The world was still a Saturday mall. Her bare feet were still out the window of her own car, long toes, high arches, notoriously ticklish in a way this man did not know yet and Chris wanted him to find out.
She nodded once.
He touched the left sole with two fingers.
Not a grab. A test. Pads of his fingers in the soft center of the arch, light, as if he were checking temperature. Kristen’s whole foot jerked. The book slid. A sound came out of her that she swallowed halfway, too high for a parking lot. His eyes flicked from the sole to her face and the almost-smile became real, because he had felt the jerk and he understood it immediately.
“Ticklish.”
“Don’t—” She laughed, already, the ugly early laugh, and did not pull the foot away. “Don’t start that here. There are people.”
He did not start that, not fully. He left the two fingers where they were and drew a slow line from the center of the arch toward the ball of her foot, and her toes clenched so hard the knuckles went pale. She thrashed as much as a woman with her heels hooked on a car door could thrash. The other foot kicked air. She clapped her free hand over her mouth and still made a noise into her palm.
He took his fingers off.
The absence was almost worse. Kristen lay back against the seat with her feet still hanging, chest going, paperback crushed to her stomach, and looked at him like she had not decided whether to be angry. She was not angry. She was bright-hot and ridiculous and wet-eyed from one line on one arch in a mall lot.
“Okay,” she said. “Okay. You felt that.”
“I felt that.”
“My husband is going to lose his mind.”
“He know you’re out here?”
“He sent me out here.” She heard how that sounded and did not clean it up. “He’s had this… interest. Sharing them. With another foot person. I told him if it was ever anyone it would look like—” She stopped, because finishing that sentence in a parking lot at a man she knew from a gym was a lot. “You. Someone like you. We joked about it. Then I saw you looking this morning and he told me to come fish.”
The man glanced at her hanging feet again, then at the lot, then back at her. He was still close. He had not put his hands in his pockets. He looked like he wanted the other sole and was choosing not to take it in front of the pretzel shop.
“You want to stay out here and hope nobody from preschool walks by,” he said, “or you want to go somewhere those get a proper look?”
Kristen’s phone buzzed on the console. She knew it was Chris without looking. She picked it up one-handed.
Anyone?
She typed with her thumb, the other hand still holding the ruined page, her left sole still tingling where two fingers had been.
Him. Gym guy. He touched one. I jumped. He knows they’re ticklish now.
The three dots came and went.
Invite him. If you’re comfortable. You said knowing him made it different.
She stared at the text. She stared at her own feet in the window, long toes, sun on the arches, the one sole already pinker than the other. She stared at the man who had watched her on a mat and then found her in a lot like the net had actually worked.
“What’s your name?” she asked.
“Marcus.”
It suited the face she had already had in her head. She gave him hers, first name only, the way you did when the rest of the biography — three kids, former teacher, the pink thing in the drawer — did not belong in a first conversation over a car door.
“Marcus. My husband says if I’m comfortable I should invite you somewhere less… mall.”
“Are you comfortable?”
She looked at her feet instead of his face. That was easier. They were still out. She had not pulled them in when he asked. She had not pulled them in when he touched. The stretch on the mat had been a flex. This was a door.
“More than I would be if you were some random,” she said. “That’s the true part. The rest of me is a mom who is going to have to pick up kids at three and pretend this didn’t happen. So if we do more, it has to be now, and it can’t be here, because I will scream if you do that line again and I do not want to explain that to security.”
Marcus’s laugh was quiet. He looked at her soles one more time, thorough, like he was taking a last public inventory — length of toes, height of arch, the shine in the center, the way the left one still twitched when his shadow moved across it.
“I have a place twenty minutes from here,” he said. “Or you name a park with no playground on it. Your call. I’m not following you home unless you want that problem.”
“Not home.” The word came out fast. Home had shin guards in the hall and recital notes on the fridge. “Your place. I text him the address. That’s the deal. And it’s feet. That’s what he asked for. That’s what you were looking at. I’m not—” She stopped again, because the sentence about her body and her toys and the break she might someday offer to get someone off her soles was a Chapter she was not in yet. “It’s feet.”
“Feet,” he said. “I can live on feet.”
He said it looking at them, and the way he said live made her toes curl without anyone touching them.
Kristen pulled her heels off the frame. The lot air felt colder the second her soles left it. She sat in the car with her bare feet on the mat and the book in her lap and typed Chris the address Marcus recited, plus twenty minutes. He knows the deal. I’ll call if I want out.
Chris sent back a single word.
Go.
She started the engine. Marcus stepped back from the door. For a second they were just two people in a mall lot on Saturday, one of them a woman who still had a bent paperback and a ponytail, the other a man who had now felt how hard her arch jumped under two fingers.
“Don’t be gentle when we get there just because there were people here,” she said, and then she heard herself, thirty-six, three kids, and clapped her mouth shut on a grin that was half horror. “I mean. They’re really ticklish. You’re going to find out anyway. I’m just saying I know what I walked into.”
Marcus looked at her feet on the pedals, then at her face.
“I was not planning on gentle,” he said.
She pulled out of the space with her window still down and the sun still on her ankles and the ghost of his fingers still in the center of her left arch. In the rearview he was walking to a dark car two rows over. The net had worked. The gym had followed her into the lot. The woman in the family photographs was driving toward a stranger’s address with her sneakers on the passenger floor and her husband’s permission in her pocket, and her feet — long toes, high arches, notoriously, stupidly ticklish — were already braced for the moment there would be no window and no book and no mall to hide the sound.
She did not pull out.
The engine was on. The address was in the phone. Chris’s Go was still lit on the screen. Marcus was a dark car two rows back, and the smart thing — the mom thing, the three-o’clock-pickup thing — was to roll the window up and drive.
Kristen sat with her bare feet on the pedals and the paperback in the passenger footwell and felt the left arch still jumping where two fingers had been. The lot went on being a lot. Carts. Sun. A kid crying at a minivan. She put the car in park again, killed the engine, and hung both feet back out the window before she could talk herself out of it.
It was a worse idea the second time. That was why she did it.
Marcus saw the feet come back out. He walked over without the hesitation of a first approach. He stopped at the same yard of lane and looked at what she had put back on offer: long toes, high arches, the left sole already a little pinker than the right, both of them in the sun like she had decided the mall was allowed to watch.
“Changed your mind about leaving?” he asked.
“Changed my mind about giving you only two fingers in a parking lot.” She heard how that sounded and laughed into it, hot-faced. “Chris is going to read the text log and think I lost my mind. I probably have. You can—” She glanced at a couple passing with bags, two rows over, not looking. “You can do it properly. If someone walks by I will die. That’s the risk. I’m leaving them out anyway.”
Marcus looked at the lot, then at her soles, then at her face.
“Say stop and I stop,” he said. “Say quiet and I go lighter. I’m not trying to get you a security escort.”
“Just don’t be gentle,” she said, for the second time that hour, and then she put the back of her wrist in her teeth because the woman in the family photographs did not say things like that with her feet hanging out of a Honda.
He took the left foot in both hands.
Not two fingers. The whole sole. His palm under the heel, thumbs already finding the high arch, the long toes trapped loosely so she could kick and not go anywhere. Kristen’s body tried to fold forward in the seat. A sound came out of her, high and stupid, and she bit it in half.
He started in the center.
That was the worst place. Chris knew it. She knew it. Marcus found it in three seconds of looking at how the skin creased and went to work like he had been handed a map. Thumbs pressing up into the softest part of the arch, then sliding toward the ball, then back, a slow grind that was not a massage. Kristen thrashed. The car door took her heel. Her other foot kicked the mirror frame and made it shudder. She laughed into her wrist, then into the open air, then clapped her own hand over her mouth while her eyes watered.
A woman with a Target bag crossed the lane behind him. Kristen saw her over Marcus’s shoulder, saw the woman’s glance tick off the hanging feet and the man holding them and then flick away, polite, refusing the picture. The refusal made it worse. They were public and not public. Her sole was in a stranger-from-the-gym’s hands and the world had decided not to see it.
“People,” she got out.
“I see them.” He did not let go. He changed texture instead of pressure: the pads of his fingers skating the same center he had just ground, light, fast, the flutter that turned her laugh into something she could not swallow. Her toes splayed. They clenched. They splayed again. The long toes he had watched on the mat were doing the whole show against his knuckles.
“Ticklish doesn’t cover it,” he said, almost to the foot. “You jump if I think about moving.”
“Don’t narrate—” She broke off into a shriek she chopped short, because a dad and two kids were coming out of the crosswalk three spaces down. Marcus froze the motion without releasing the foot. Kristen hung there, sole in his hands, chest heaving, smiling a bright fake smile at nobody, until the kids were past the carts. Then his thumb sank back into the arch and she folded again, laughing for real, ugly and wet.
Her phone buzzed on the dash.
She had to peel one hand off her mouth to grab it. Marcus did not pause. He switched to the line under her toes — the thin, vicious strip that made her kick the door — while she tried to see the screen through tears.
Chris: You went quiet. Still there?
She typed with her thumb, misspelling half of it.
Window. He’s got the left one. I can’t be quiet. Lot is full. I’m dying.
Chris: Good dying or out dying?
She looked at her own foot in Marcus’s hands. The sole was pink now, shiny in the sun, the arch flexing against his thumbs like it was trying to hide inside itself. She was thirty-six. She had a recital next weekend. She was going to have to pick children up at three and talk about cake.
Good. Don’t stop him. I’m an idiot.
Chris: Ask him for the other one. Then go to the address. I want the private version too.
Marcus had already taken the other one.
He stacked them.
Both of her bare feet in his grip, heels together, arches offered to the lane, long toes pointing at his chest. The position made her feel more hung-out than before, more like the fishing joke had stopped being a joke. He raked both centers at once with his fingertips and Kristen made a noise that was not appropriate for a mall. She thrashed so hard the seatbelt buckle dug into her hip. Her ponytail stuck to her mouth. She spat it out and laughed and tried to say quiet and said fuck instead, whispered, vicious, helpless.
“Under the toes,” he said, and did it.
Both sets. The flutter. No mercy in a public place except the mercy of not doing it louder. Kristen’s head tipped back against the rest. She could see sky and a sliver of a light pole and the idea of a security golf cart that was not there yet. Her feet tried to clap together. He did not let them. He kept the soles open and worked the arches in small cruel circles until she was shaking in the seat, the paperback on the floor, the phone clutched to her collarbone, Chris’s last text glowing against her skin.
A man on a phone walked within a row. He looked. He looked longer than the Target woman. Marcus did not turn. He eased the flutter into a slow press, which was not kindness; the slow press in the center of both arches made Kristen sob-laugh into her teeth and curl forward until her forehead almost hit the wheel.
“Okay,” she gasped. “Okay—okay—window’s done. Window’s done. I will scream. I will actually scream and then I will have to invent a wasp.”
Marcus slowed. He did not drop her feet. He held them, thumbs resting in the wet centers, and looked at what he had done: two wrecked soles, pink, ticking with leftover nerves, long toes still clenched. He looked like he had at the gym, only now he had data. He knew the map.
“Address still good?” he asked.
“Address is good.” She pulled her feet in. The instant they left his hands they felt huge, loud, too sensitive for the pedals. She sat in the car with her knees up and her soles on the seat edge and wiped her face with the hem of the rec-league shirt. “You were not gentle.”
“You told me twice.”
“I’m going to tell my husband you stacked them in a parking lot.”
“Tell him they jumped the same way on both sides.” Marcus stepped back from the door, glanced once more at her feet on the seat, and tipped his head toward his car. “Follow me. If you change your mind at a light, change your mind. I’ll see the Honda turn off.”
She did not change her mind at a light.
She drove with the window still cracked and the air hitting the damp of her arches every time she shifted her foot on the pedal. The mall shrank in the mirror. The book stayed on the floor. Her phone buzzed through a string of Chris, and she answered at a red light with one thumb.
Leaving the lot. He stacked them. I almost screamed. People saw and pretended not to. On the way to his. Feet only. I’ll text when I’m in the door.
Chris: How bad?
She looked at her own left sole against the pedal. The center was still pink. She could feel every groove of the rubber.
Worse than you. Different than you. He found the middle in three seconds. I am in so much trouble.
Chris: Good. Don’t you dare put socks on before you get there.
She laughed at the light, a leftover, shaky sound, and the car behind her honked. She went. Twenty minutes of ordinary road. Strip plazas. A grocery she used on Tuesdays. The double life riding with her in the cabin: shin guards at home, a man from the gym ahead in a dark car, her notoriously ticklish feet bare on the pedals because her husband had told her not to cover them.
Marcus’s place was a ground-floor unit off a quiet lot, no playground, no preschool decal in any window. She parked. She sat for ten seconds with her hands on the wheel and her soles on the mat and the mom voice listing every reason to start the engine again. Then she picked up the phone.
Here. Going in. If I text the word recital, call me and I’ll come home.
Chris: Understood. Tell me how loud it is when it isn’t a mall.
Kristen got out barefoot. The asphalt was rough. She took the sneakers in one hand and the phone in the other and did not put the sneakers on. Marcus was already at his door. He looked at her bare feet on his walkway, at the long toes and the sun-pink arches and the way she walked like the ground was too much after the window, and he held the door.
She stepped through.
Behind her the Saturday lot went on being ordinary. Ahead of her there was no window to stuff a laugh into, and no Target bag to make him freeze, and no book to hide her face. Just the feet she had fished with, and a man who already knew they jumped if he thought about moving, and a husband two suburbs over waiting for a report on how loud it got when the only risk left was how ticklish she actually was.
His place was smaller than she had pictured and cleaner than she had feared. Blinds half-drawn. A couch that had seen use. No photographs of children on the fridge, which helped. Kristen stood on his mat just inside the door with her sneakers in one hand and her phone in the other and her bare feet on someone else’s floor, and the first thing she said was not about the feet.
“I only came because I know your face.”
Marcus closed the door. He did not lock it in a way that made a show of locking it. He looked at her the way he had in the lot, then at the long toes on his mat.
“Gym,” he said. “Not a guy from a van. I got it.”
“If you had been a stranger at that window I would have pulled them in and driven to Target like a coward.” She set the sneakers down. She set the phone on his counter, face-up, Chris’s thread still open. “I’m a mom. I’m supposed to be at a birthday party circuit, not in a ground-floor unit with my shoes off. Knowing you from the weights is the only reason this doesn’t feel like I lost my mind in a parking lot.”
“You did lose your mind in a parking lot,” he said. “You just recognized the person you lost it with.”
That pulled a laugh out of her that was still shaky from the window. He pointed at the couch. She sat. The cushion dipped. She tucked one foot under her by habit and then, because the habit was a lie, she put both soles on the edge of the coffee table instead, offered without being asked. Long toes. High arches. The left one still pinker from the lot. The centers still too awake.
“Feet,” she said. “That was the deal I texted him. He knows where I am. If I say recital, this ends.”
“Recital,” Marcus repeated, like he was putting the word in a pocket. “All right.”
He sat on the table facing her, her soles between them, and took both feet in his hands with none of the public caution. No Target bags. No kids in a crosswalk. The thumbs went straight to the centers of the arches and pressed.
Kristen folded.
The sound that came out of her had no mall in it. It was the real one, the one she stuffed into pillows at home when Chris forgot to be careful. She thrashed back into the couch. Her knees tried to snap shut and his hips were already there, keeping her open. He worked both arches at once, grinding, then fluttering, then grinding again, and he watched her feet while he did it the same way he had watched them through studio glass — like they were the whole point of the room.
“Worse than the window,” she got out, laughing already, wet-eyed already. “That’s not fair. You already mapped them.”
“You gave me a map in a Honda.” He raked the line under her toes and her long toes splayed so hard they shook. “Gym was the looking. Lot was the test. This is the part your husband asked for.”
She should have hated that he brought Chris into it. She did not. The knowing — gym face, husband’s permission, her own mouth saying a good-looking Black guy into a pillow months ago — was the only reason she kept her soles on the table instead of kicking free and going for the door.
He was not gentle.
He had told her he would not be. He used his nails in the high arches until she shrieked and clapped a hand over her own mouth and then took the hand away because there was no neighbor with a slushie here, only blinds and a couch and a man who was enjoying the way her feet jumped. He stacked them the way he had at the car and raked both soles from heel to toe in one long stroke. Kristen’s whole body jackknifed. She laughed until she hiccupped. She tried to say wait and said his name instead, first-name familiar, gym-familiar, which made it worse and better.
“Marcus—Jesus—”
He hooked her ankles under one arm the way he had wanted to in the lot and went after the inner edges, the thin skin along the arches that made her kick Chris in bed. She kicked him. He took it and did not stop. The soles pinked. They shone. The long toes clenched and opened and clenched. She was thirty-six and a former teacher and a woman who packed birthday bags, and she was thrashing on a stranger-who-was-not-a-stranger’s couch with her rec-league shirt rucked up and her ponytail in her mouth.
He slowed only to change attack.
Knuckles in the centers. Then one fingertip writing the same circle in the worst spot on the left foot until she was sobbing laughter into the cushion. Then the right foot the same way, thorough, patient, mean. He looked satisfied. Not rushed. A man who had watched those feet on a mat and waited through a mall and now had them.
Kristen’s phone lit on the counter. She could not reach it. Marcus glanced at the screen without taking both hands off her.
“He says how loud.”
“Tell him—” She broke off into a scream-laugh when his nail found the left heel, the spot she hated. “Tell him I can’t text. Tell him I know your face and I’m still an idiot.”
Marcus did not text for her. He went back to the stacked soles and the flutter under both sets of toes until she was shaking too hard to make words. Then he eased off just enough that she could breathe, thumbs resting in the wet centers, her feet ticking in his grip.
“Comfortable?” he asked.
It was a rotten question. She was wrecked. She was barefoot in a ground-floor unit on a Saturday with kids due at three. She was also, treacherously, still on the table.
“I’m comfortable that you’re not a random,” she said, hoarse. “I’m not comfortable about my feet. They’re — they’re worse when I can’t pretend it’s a joke at a window.”
“You want a break.”
She did. The client-beat she had almost offered Chris in a different life sat on her tongue: take something else, just get off the soles. She swallowed it. Not yet. Feet was the deal. Feet was what Chris had sent her fishing for.
“A minute,” she said. “Then you can ruin them again. I know what I walked into. I said that in the lot. I’m saying it here because I know you from the gym and that is the only reason I haven’t used the recital word.”
Marcus nodded once. He set her feet down on the table and let them twitch in the air like they did not believe they were free. Kristen stared at her own soles. Pink. Shiny. Long toes still half-clenched. The arches looked like they belonged to someone who posted photos for strangers and then went to a dance recital like the photos were a different woman.
She laughed, wrecked and goofy, the streak that did not match the family pictures.
“He’s going to want every second of this,” she said, meaning Chris. “The stack. The heel. How I said your name. How I only stayed because I knew your face.”
“He can have the report.” Marcus’s hands hovered over her arches again, not touching yet. “Minute’s up when you put them back in my hands. You don’t have to say anything. Just give them to me.”
Kristen looked at the door. She looked at the phone. She looked at the man from the weights who had followed a pair of bare feet from a studio to a mall to a couch.
She put her feet back in his hands.
He started in the centers without warming up, and the sound she made had no window left to hide in, and she did not say recital, because knowing him was still enough, and because her husband had asked for this exact trouble, and because the wholesome woman in the photographs had never been the whole story.
The second wave on the couch did not have a mall in it and did not have a minute in it either.
Marcus took the feet she had put back in his hands and went at the centers like the pause had been a courtesy he was done paying. Thumbs grinding both high arches. Fingers raking the line under the long toes. The stacked stroke from heel to ball that made her jackknife. Kristen laughed until her stomach cramped. She kicked him and hit nothing that mattered. The rec-league shirt was rucked under her breasts. Her ponytail had come loose. She was thirty-six and a mother of three and she could hear her own voice filling a ground-floor unit on a Saturday like it belonged to someone who did not pack recital snacks.
“Wait—” It was not recital. Recital was the door. This was something else. “Marcus. Wait. I can’t— I can’t do another ten minutes of just that. I’ll throw up. I’m not joking.”
He slowed. He did not let go. His thumbs stayed in the wet centers of her soles, a threat dressed as a rest. Her feet ticked against his palms. She hated how small they looked there. She hated how much Chris was going to like the report.
“You want a break from these,” Marcus said.
“Yes.”
“Breaks cost.”
Kristen shut her eyes. The beat she had almost told her husband to put in a story — offer the rest of her to get someone off her feet — was sitting in her mouth with gym-salt and parking-lot air. The wholesome photograph-woman would have used the safe word and driven to the birthday party. The other woman, the one with a following for her arches and a pink thing in a nightstand at home, opened her eyes.
“What does it cost?”
“You say it.” He drew one fingertip down the left arch, light, and she jerked so hard the couch moved. “Not a hint. You tell me what you’re offering so I get off these long toes for a while.”
She laughed, wrecked and ugly, because of course he would make her say it. Of course the man who had watched her on a mat would not let the mom-voice do the dirty work in mime.
“You can have the rest of me,” she said. It came out flat first, then hotter when his fingertip paused on the worst spot and she had to push the rest past a gasp. “Not just the feet. Mouth. Hands. You can fuck me. You can— God, you can do whatever gets your hands off my soles for five minutes before I start crying for real. That’s the offer. I’m a married suburban idiot who went fishing and I am asking you to use something that isn’t my arches.”
Marcus looked at her face, then at the feet in his hands, then at the phone on the counter.
“He know that part?”
“He knows I have a wild streak he likes to pretend he invented.” She swallowed. “He knows about the drawer at home. He doesn’t know I’m saying this in your living room. I’ll tell him. After. If you stop tickling long enough for me to have a brain.”
Marcus set her left foot down.
Only the left.
The right one he kept, and he punished it while he thought, a slow cruel circle in the center of the arch that made her sob-laugh and clutch the cushion. Then he set that one down too. The absence was a hole. Her soles twitched on the table, pink, shiny, long toes still half-clenched, waiting for a hit that did not come.
“Shirt off,” he said. “You offered a body. I want to see the rest of the woman from the gym.”
Kristen pulled the rec-league shirt over her head. Sports bra after. The air in the unit hit skin that usually only saw a locked bathroom and a husband. She was not a magazine. She was thirty-six and three pregnancies and athletic in a practical way, and she watched his eyes go from her feet to her mouth to her chest and back to her feet like he might change his mind and stack them again.
He did not stack them.
He hooked his fingers in the waist of the capris and she lifted her hips and let him take those too, and the underwear with them, until she was on his couch with nothing on but the ponytail falling down and the flush from laughing. The contrast landed in her like a slap she had asked for: birthday bags, classroom voice, bare on a gym-guy’s couch because her arches had broken her.
“You can still say recital,” he said.
“I’m not saying recital.”
He kissed her mouth first, which she had not expected. It was not tender. It was a man tasting the laugh still on her teeth. Then his mouth went down. Throat. The sports-bra line that wasn’t there anymore. He sucked a nipple and she made a sound that was not a tickle-sound and her traitorous foot kicked the table anyway. He caught the foot without looking, held it still, and kept his mouth on her breast until her head tipped back.
“That’s not off the soles,” she gasped. “That’s you holding one.”
“Insurance.” He bit, light, and she arched. “I get off them when I’m inside you. Not before.”
He opened his jeans with the other hand. She watched because she had offered and because looking away would have been a lie. He was already hard. He shoved his pants down far enough and pulled her hips to the edge of the couch and set the head of him against her. She was wet. The tickling had done that as much as the mouth. The fishing had done that. Chris’s Go had done that. She was a mom with a secret following and she was slick for the man who had mapped her feet in a Honda.
He pushed in.
Kristen’s laugh broke into a groan. He filled her in one slow shove that made her hands fist in the cushion, and the foot he was still holding jerked in his grip like it wanted the old torture back and also never wanted it again. He did not tickle that sole. He held it open, thumb in the arch, a reminder, and fucked her with deep unhurried strokes that had nothing to do with a mall window.
“This is the break,” he said against her mouth. “You earned it by asking. You keep earning it by taking it.”
She took it. She was loud. The unit had blinds and no playground and she still heard herself and thought of the woman in the family photographs and laughed once, helpless, at the gap. He found an angle that made her swear. He kept the one foot hostage, thumb pressing the center of the arch in time with his hips, not a full attack, a metronome of I could. Every time she got close he pressed harder into the sole and the laugh mixed into the moan and she could not tell which one she was doing.
“Chris is going to want this part,” she said, wrecked. “He’s going to want that I bought a break with my—”
Marcus thrust and the sentence died. He let go of the foot.
Both hands on her hips. No insurance. The soles were free on the air, twitching, ignored, and the ignoring was almost as filthy as the flutter had been. He fucked her like the feet had been the door and this was the room. Kristen came first, surprised by it, a tight helpless clench that pulled a sound out of her she would have to describe later whether she wanted to or not. He did not stop. He dragged her through it until she was shaking and then he pulled out and came on her stomach with a curse, one hand braced on the couch, the other — traitor — catching her right ankle so her sole was open in his peripheral vision the whole time.
For a few seconds there was only breathing.
Kristen stared at the ceiling. Sweat at her hairline. Come on her belly. Her feet still up on the table edge like they had not gotten the message that the deal had changed. The pink toy at home felt like a joke compared to the fact of him. The gym felt like a year ago. It had been four hours.
Marcus ran one finger through the mess on her skin, then — because he was who he was — down to her left sole, and painted a wet streak across the arch.
She jerked. She laughed. She almost kicked him in the face.
“That’s not a break,” she said.
“Break’s over.” He smiled at the streak on her arch. “You offered a body to get me off these. I got off. They’re still the reason I walked up to a Honda.”
He licked the center of that sole.
Kristen screamed laughter and tried to twist away and his hands were already there, stacking her feet again, mouth on the arch he had marked, tongue in the worst spot, and the break she had earned was done. She thrashed. She was naked and loud and ticklish beyond sense, and he ate the laugh out of her feet like the sex had only been a pause between courses.
Her phone lit.
She could not reach it. She did not need to. She knew the text. How loud.
“Louder,” she told the ceiling, while Marcus’s tongue wrote a circle in her arch and her long toes clenched in his hair. “Tell him I paid. Tell him it didn’t last. Tell him I know his face and I still can’t get my feet back.”
Marcus did not stop to tell anyone anything. He held her stacked soles to his mouth and tickled them with his tongue until she was crying real tears of laughter, naked on a gym-guy’s couch, the wholesome day still waiting out there with cake and shin guards, and the wild streak finally, finally matching the rest of the room.
When he finally lifted his head her arches were shining and her voice was gone and the break she had bought was a story she was going to have to take home in her mouth and give to her husband in order.
“Socks,” she whispered, not meaning it.
“Not yet,” Marcus said, and put two fingers back in the center of her left arch just to watch her jump. “You still have until three. Recital’s a word. Use it or give me the feet.”
Kristen looked at her own wrecked soles.
She gave him the feet.
She put the capris back on inside out the first time and had to laugh at herself, wrecked and goofy, standing on his mat with come wiped off her stomach with a gym towel and her soles still ticking like they had a pulse of their own. The sports bra went on crooked. The rec-league shirt smelled like his couch. She did not ask for a shower. A shower would have made her late and would have washed off the report.
Marcus watched her dress from the table. He looked at her feet until the sneakers went over them, and even then he looked at the canvas like he could see the arches through it.
“Three o’clock,” she said.
“I remember.”
“If I come back to the gym I will stretch on the other side of the room.”
“No you won’t.”
She almost smiled. She picked up the phone. Chris had sent three messages she had not been able to answer. She typed in the doorway, thumbs clumsy.
On the way home. Intact. No recital. I have to tell you in person or I will crash the car.
The reply was already waiting when she hit the first light.
Kids get dropped at 3:10. You’ve got a window. Start talking when you park.
She drove barefoot inside the sneakers, no socks, because he had told her not to put socks on before Marcus’s and putting them on after felt like cheating. Every time she pressed the pedal the left arch lit up where a tongue had been. She thought about cake and shin guards and the word stacked. She thought about the sentence she had said out loud to get a break and how short the break had been. She thought about the woman in the family photographs and could not find her in the Honda for a full mile.
The driveway was ordinary. A sprinkler. A neighbor’s bin. Chris opened the door before she got the key out.
He looked at her face first. Then at the sneakers. Then at the fact that she had not put her hair back up.
“Inside,” he said.
The house was still the house. Recital notice on the fridge. Someone’s water bottle on its side. The quiet before 3:10. Kristen toed the sneakers off on the same kitchen tile where she had flexed for him that morning and her bare feet looked like evidence. Pink centers. A faint shine still in the left arch if you knew to look. Long toes that curled when his eyes landed on them.
Chris did not touch them yet.
“Tell me,” he said.
She told him from the mat.
The lot first, because the lot was the joke they had built. The book she had not read. The feet out the window. Marcus walking up like the gym had followed her. Two fingers in the left arch. The jump. The Target woman who had looked away. The stack at the window, both soles in the sun, the dad with two kids she had had to fake-smile past while she died. The texts. His Go.
Chris’s mouth had gone loose in the way it did when the interest in him got ahead of his face. He was hard in his jeans and not hiding it. She kept talking because if she stopped she would start editing, and he had not asked for an edited version.
“His place was a ground floor. I said I only went because I knew his face. That’s true. If he’d been a random I would have pulled them in and bought pretzels.” She swallowed. “He sat me on the couch and put my feet on the table and he was not gentle. He already had the map from the Honda. Centers. Under the toes. Heels. He stacked them again. I said his name. I could not text you. I told him to tell you I was an idiot.”
“How loud,” Chris said. Not a question.
“Loud. No window to hide it. I laughed until I hiccupped. I kicked him. He did not care.” Her face was hot. The mom-voice wanted to tidy this into a cute story. She did not let it. “Then I asked for a break.”
Chris went very still.
“I offered the rest of me,” she said. “He made me say it. Not a hint. Mouth, hands, he could fuck me, whatever got him off my soles for five minutes. I said I was a married suburban idiot who went fishing. I said I would tell you after. I’m telling you.”
The kitchen clock moved. 2:51. She kept going, because the silence was going to make her lie by omission and she was already in too far for omission.
“Shirt off. Everything off. He held one foot while he was inside me like insurance. Thumb in the arch on the beat. I came like that. He came on my stomach. Then he wiped it on my sole and licked it off and the break was over.” She laughed once, helpless, at her own ceiling. “He went back to my feet with his mouth. I gave them to him again. I did not say recital. I had until three and I gave him the feet.”
Chris let out a breath that was almost a laugh and almost not. He crouched, the same crouch from the morning, and he looked at her soles on their tile like he was reading a language only the two of them spoke. He touched the left arch with one finger, light, and she jerked hard enough to catch the counter.
“That’s the spot,” he said.
“That’s the spot.”
“He found it in three seconds.”
“He found it in three seconds.”
Chris put his mouth where his finger had been, just a press, not a full attack, and Kristen laughed into her fist because her body did not know the difference between a husband on kitchen tile and a gym guy on a couch. He stopped. He stayed crouched. His voice came out rough.
“You liked that he knew you from the weights.”
“Yes.”
“You liked that I sent you.”
“Yes.”
“You liked paying for the break and not getting to keep it.”
She shut her eyes. The honest answer was the wild-streak answer. “Yes.”
2:56. A car door slammed somewhere on the street and both of them flinched, then it was the wrong house. Chris stood. He kissed her mouth and tasted, she knew, everything she had just said. His hand stayed off her feet. The off was loud.
“Socks,” he said. “Kids. You can be the other woman again after bath time.”
She put socks on. Ankle socks, white, the kind that went with the photographs. The arches disappeared. The long toes disappeared. She scraped her hair into a ponytail that almost held. She washed her face. She looked like Saturday pickup. She did not feel like Saturday pickup. The left sole still had a ghost of a tongue in it every time she flexed inside the sock.
The minivan arrived at 3:09. Chaos returned on schedule. Cupcakes. A lost shoe that was not hers. A story about a piñata she only half heard. Chris took bags. She kissed hair that was not Marcus’s and packed water bottles and was the woman on the fridge magnet for two hours without a crack showing, except once, when she sat on the couch during a cartoon and Chris looked at her socked feet and she had to get up and go to the kitchen so she would not laugh in front of a talking animal.
Bath time. Stories. Lights out.
The house went dim and expensive with quiet. Kristen stood in their bedroom and took the socks off like she was taking off a costume. Chris was already on the edge of the bed. She put her bare feet in his lap before he asked.
“Again,” he said. “Slower. The stack at the window.”
She gave it to him slower. The Target bag. The fake smile. The way Marcus had frozen the flutter when the dad walked by and then put the thumb back the second the kids were past. She gave him the couch. The minute that had not been a minute. The sentence she had to say to buy the break. The insurance-thumb. The lick. The second yes, the one where she put her feet back in Marcus’s hands with her own body still wet from him.
Chris was touching her while she talked. Not tickling, not at first. Holding the arches, tracing the long toes, mapping the pink that had faded and was still, if you knew, there. When she got to the lick he did tickle, sudden, two fingers in the center of the left foot, and she laughed into a pillow the way she had in Tampa years ago, except now the laugh had a mall and a gym and another man’s name in it.
“Fishing again?” he asked, when she could breathe.
Kristen stared at the ceiling. Recital next weekend. Grocery list on her phone. A man named Marcus who would be at the weights on Tuesday.
“Not tomorrow,” she said. “I’m not a maniac.” She turned her head on the pillow and looked at her husband, at the interest in his face that had never been anger, at the feet in his lap that had been out a window for him. “Another Saturday. Kids at a party. I’ll stretch at the gym. If he’s looking I won’t pull them in. If you tell me to roll the window down I will roll the window down.”
“And if he wants more than feet.”
She thought about the cost. She thought about saying it out loud. She thought about the photographs and the drawer and the fact that the wholesome version had never been the whole story.
“Then I text you,” she said. “And I make him hear me say it. And I come home and I sit on this bed and I tell you how loud it was when there wasn’t a mall.”
Chris kissed the high arch of her right foot, careful, almost polite, which somehow wrecked her more than Marcus’s nails. She flexed against his mouth. Long toes. Pronounced arch. Notoriously, stupidly ticklish. A suburban mom with a secret that now had a name and an address and a husband who wanted the next report more than he wanted the lie that fishing had been a one-time joke.
“Tuesday,” Chris said against her sole. “Stretch where he can see.”
“Tuesday,” she said.
In the dark her phone lit once on the nightstand. She did not check it. She already knew it would either be nothing or a gym schedule. She left the socks off. She left the window of the next Saturday open in the room with them. She fell asleep with her feet in her husband’s hands and the ghost of another man’s thumbs still in the centers, and the woman in the family photographs slept too, because she had always been real — she had just never been the entire story.
FOR COMMISSIONS, DM ON DEVIANTART: https://www.deviantart.com/natorlstudio
The Saturday morning class let out in a wash of sweat and borrowed playlists. Kristen lingered on her mat a minute longer than the women who had carpool deadlines. Thirty-six, three kids, a former classroom still living in the way she stacked her water bottle and folded the towel into a neat rectangle. From the front she looked like what she was on paper: suburban mom, athletic in a practical way, hair in a ponytail that had started neat and ended damp. The other version of her — the one with the following she never mentioned at pickup — was in her feet.
She had kicked the sneakers off halfway through cooldown. Habit. Her soles liked the mat better than the shoes after forty minutes of work. Long toes. High, pronounced arches that showed when she pointed. Skin still pink from the room. She sat with one leg folded and the other extended, folded forward over the long leg, and reached for the toes the way the instructor had said to, except the instructor had already left and Kristen was not stretching for form anymore. She was stretching because it felt good and because, in the back of her mind, she knew what her feet looked like when she did this.
She felt the look before she placed it.
Not on her face. Not on the black capris or the faded rec-league shirt. On her feet. Mid-room, near the free weights that bordered the studio glass, a man she had seen here for months was not putting plates away. He was standing with a towel around his neck, good-looking in the uncomplicated way some men were after a lift — dark skin, close-cut hair, the kind of build that made the gym lighting do him favors — and his eyes were on her bare soles.
Kristen’s first instinct, the mom instinct, was to tuck them under her thighs and laugh it off at herself. She did not do that.
She flexed instead. Slow. The arch of the extended foot lifted off the mat and settled. Her toes spread and closed. She told herself she was just finishing the stretch. She knew she was not just finishing the stretch. The private little thrill she got when strangers online commented on a photo of her painted toes was the same heat, only this one had a body attached to it and a gym full of people who were not looking.
He noticed the flex. She saw it in the way his mouth moved, not quite a smile. He did not walk over. He did not pretend he had been looking at the clock. He watched her feet the way people watched a screen they had not meant to stop on.
Kristen switched legs.
The other foot came out, same long toes, same high arch, a faint line of mat-texture on the heel. She folded over it and stayed there longer than the stretch required. Sweat cooled at her hairline. Somewhere a weight stack clacked. A woman laughed by the water fountain. Kristen’s world had narrowed to the mat, the open sole, and the man who had not looked away.
She had joked with Chris about this.
Not this exact man. The idea of him. Chris had had an interest for years in sharing her feet with another foot lover. They had talked about it in bed the way some couples talked about vacations they would never book. She had said, half into the pillow, that if it ever happened she would want it to be a good-looking Black guy. She had said it like a joke that was not entirely a joke. Chris had gone quiet in the good way. After that the jokes had edges. After that she had started leaving her shoes off more often when she stretched at home where he could see.
The gym was not home.
She sat up, rolled her ankles, and let both feet rest on the mat with the soles half-turned toward the weights. An invitation she could still deny if anyone asked. He took one step closer. Not into her space. Into a better angle. She could see he was looking at the arches now, at the way the skin creased when she pointed and flexed. Her feet were notoriously ticklish. Chris knew that in the particular, lived-in way a husband of years knew it. This man did not know it yet. He was only looking. The looking was already doing something to her that she would have to take home and decide whether to confess.
She picked up the towel and dragged it once over each sole, slow enough to be drying them, slow enough to be showing them. Then she stood, still barefoot, and walked to her bag at the edge of the studio. The floor was cool. Her toes spread on it. She did not put the sneakers on immediately. She sat on the bench, bag open, water in her hand, and left her feet in the aisle where the path from the weights to the door had to pass.
He passed.
He did not speak. His eyes dropped to her feet as he went by, held, lifted to her face for half a second — not rude, not shy — and then he was gone toward the locker hallway. Kristen sat on the bench with her heart going in a rhythm that had nothing to do with the class. She put the sneakers on without socks, the way she sometimes did when she wanted to feel the canvas on still-warm skin, and she drove home with the radio lower than usual.
The house was the controlled chaos she always came back to. Someone’s shin guard in the hall. A recital notice on the fridge. Chris at the counter with coffee that had gone cold because the morning had gotten away from him too. The kids were at a birthday party until three. The quiet was a rare square of Saturday they usually spent catching up on nothing.
He looked at her gym bag, at her still-damp hair, at the fact that she had not launched into the class recap she usually launched into.
“Good one?” he asked.
“Mm.” She dropped the bag and leaned on the other side of the counter. Her sneakers were already off again. Habit. Her bare feet on their kitchen tile. Long toes. The arches he liked to look at when he thought she was not paying attention. “There was a guy.”
Chris’s coffee mug stopped halfway.
She told it without dressing it up. The cooldown. The sneakers off. The stretch that had gone on too long. The man from the weights who had been coming to the same gym for months. Good-looking. Black. Watching her feet, not her face. The flex she had given him on purpose. The towel on the soles. The walk to the bag with her shoes still off. The pass in the aisle where he had looked down and then at her and said nothing.
Chris listened the way he listened when the jokes stopped being jokes. His eyes had gone to her feet on the tile without him seeming to decide to look. She flexed them once, the same slow lift of the arch she had given the man on the mat, and watched her husband’s throat work.
“You didn’t pull them in,” he said. Not a question.
“No.”
“Did you want him to come over?”
Kristen breathed out through her nose. The wholesome version of her — dance recitals, birthday bags, the woman in the family photographs — would have said of course not. The other version, the one who posted her feet for strangers and owned a drawer of things the PTA did not need to know about, the one who had said a good-looking Black guy into a pillow, did not rush to close it.
“I wanted him to keep looking,” she said. “I don’t know if I wanted him to come over. In the gym? With people? I don’t know. I liked that he didn’t pretend he wasn’t doing it.”
Chris set the mug down. He came around the counter. He did not grab her. He crouched, which he did sometimes when the interest in him got specific, and he looked at her feet the way the man at the gym had looked at them, except Chris had years of knowing how ticklish they were and he did not touch them yet.
“Long toes,” he said, almost to himself. “Those arches. He got a show.”
“He got a show I let him have.”
“Would you let him have more?”
There it was. The vacation they had never booked, sitting on their kitchen tile between a shin guard and cold coffee. Kristen’s face went warm. She was thirty-six and a mother of three and she could feel the mischievous streak in her like a second pulse.
“I don’t know him,” she said. “I know his face. That’s different than a stranger from a parking lot. That’s why it didn’t feel as crazy.” She paused. “You still want the fishing thing.”
Chris had wanted the fishing thing for a year. Her in a busy mall lot, book in her lap, bare feet out the window, as if she were just airing them after errands. A net she pretended not to be holding. He had described it often enough that she could see the lot, the minivan two spaces over, the way her soles would look against painted metal.
“Today,” he said. “After this. Kids aren’t back until three. You already did the gym. You’re already barefoot in your head. Go sit in the lot and read. If nobody comes, nobody comes. If somebody does—”
“If it’s him,” she said.
They both heard it.
Chris looked up from her feet. The interest in his face was not anger. It was the same heat she had felt on the mat when she had not tucked her soles away.
“If it’s him,” he said, “you don’t have to do anything you don’t want. You can laugh and pull them in. Or you can let him find out they’re ticklish. You’ve said they are. I’ve told you they are. He doesn’t know yet.”
Kristen laughed once, short, the goofy edge of her that sat next to the polished one. “You’re really doing this. You’re sending your wife to dangle her feet out a car window because a man at 24 Hour looked at them.”
“I’m asking,” Chris said. “You’ve been posting them for people you’ll never meet. This is one you’ll recognize if he walks up. You said that made it more comfortable. So go see if he shops at the same mall we do on Saturdays. Or if he doesn’t, go see what it feels like to wait.”
She looked down at her own feet. The mat-texture had faded. The arches were still there, the long toes, the skin that went helpless if the right fingers found the center. Notoriously ticklish. A secret that was not a secret in this house and would not stay a secret if she left the window down.
“I’ll take a book,” she said.
“Take the one you never finish. You’ll want something to look at that isn’t your own toes.”
She almost told him the rest: that when the man had passed her on the bench she had thought about his hands. That she had thought about whether a foot lover from the gym would be gentle or whether he would go straight for the arches the way Chris did when he stopped being careful. That the contrast — recital mom, birthday-party mom, the woman with a pink toy in the nightstand she did not mention at lunch — was part of why the looking had landed so hard. She did not say all of that. She said:
“If he comes up to the car, I’m texting you.”
“Good.”
“If I let him touch them, I’m texting you that too.”
Chris’s mouth moved. He stood. He kissed her hair, gym-damp, and his hand found her waist and not her feet, which somehow made the feet louder.
“Go fishing,” he said.
Kristen put the sneakers back on without socks. She took the paperback from the basket under the side table, the one with the bent page from three weeks ago. She took her keys. At the door she stopped and looked back. Chris was still by the counter. He was looking at the place on the tile where her bare feet had been.
“He was really looking,” she said. “Not a glance. Looking.”
“I know.”
“I liked it.”
“I know that too.”
She left.
The Saturday light on the driveway was ordinary. A neighbor waved. A sprinkler ticked. Kristen started the car and felt her own pulse in the arches of her feet against the pedals, and she drove toward the mall lot with the book on the passenger seat and the gym still on her skin, and the man from the weights still standing in the back of her mind with a towel around his neck and his eyes on her soles.
She did not know if he would be there.
She knew she was going to roll the window down anyway.
She knew that if a shadow fell across her bare feet while she pretended to read, she would have to decide, in a parking lot in the middle of a wholesome Saturday, whether the woman in the family photographs was going to pull her toes in — or flex them again, slow, the way she had on the mat, and see what a man who already liked looking would do when he was allowed to touch.
The mall lot on Saturday at noon was a sea of hatchbacks and sunstruck windshields. Kristen parked at the far edge, two rows back from the main doors, where the walking traffic thinned but did not die. A family dragged a stroller past her bumper. Someone’s bagged pretzel threw cinnamon into the air. She killed the engine, sat with both hands on the wheel, and laughed once at herself, quiet, because the whole thing was ridiculous and she was doing it anyway.
Book. Window. Feet.
She had promised Chris.
The paperback bent open to the same dog-eared page she had not finished in three weeks. She dropped the driver’s seat back a notch, rolled the window down, and for a moment she only sat there with her sneakers still on, a suburban mom in a rec-league shirt with a gym ponytail going frizzy, looking like she had pulled over to wait for a kid who was still in the food court. Then she toed the sneakers off, peeled the invisible leftover of the class off her soles with her thumb, and lifted both feet through the open window.
The metal of the door was warm. Her heels hooked the frame. Her long toes hung in the open air. The arches — high, obvious, the ones the man at the gym had watched like a screen — faced the lane.
She felt immediately, vividly on display.
Not the clean kind of display she got from a photo she could crop and caption. This was her actual Saturday attached to her actual car in an actual lot where a woman from preschool could walk by with a slushie. Kristen opened the book and stared at a paragraph she did not read. A breeze found the damp crease of her left arch and she almost pulled in. She did not pull in. She pointed her toes once, slow, the same flex she had given him on the mat, and the thrill that went up her legs had nothing to do with literature.
She texted Chris with the book still open on her stomach.
Up. Far lot. Feeling like an idiot.
The reply came fast.
Good. Leave them out. Tell me if anyone stops.
She set the phone face-down on the console and went back to pretending to read. A man with a Home Depot bucket crossed two rows over and did not look. A teenager on a phone did not look. A woman in yoga pants glanced at the hanging feet, made the small face people made at odd parking-lot behavior, and kept walking. Kristen’s ears were hot. The mischievous streak that lived under the recital photos liked the heat. The mom streak wanted the sneakers back on.
Five minutes.
Eight.
Her soles were warming in the sun. She could feel the skin of the arches tightening the way it did on the pool deck in July. She rolled her ankles. The long toes spread and closed. She thought about the man from the weights — towel, dark skin, the look that had not been a glance — and she thought about Chris at the kitchen counter asking whether she had wanted him to come over. She still did not have a clean answer. She had an answer that lived in her feet, which were still out the window.
A shadow cut the sun on her soles.
She did not look up at once. She finished the sentence she was not reading. Then she lifted her eyes over the paperback.
It was him.
Same man. Same build. Street clothes now, not gym gear — dark shirt, jeans — but the face from the studio glass was unmistakable. He had stopped in the lane a yard from her door, not blocking it, close enough that her hanging feet were pointed more or less at his belt. He looked at them first. Then at her. Then at the book, as if he were checking whether the whole picture was what it appeared to be.
Kristen’s laugh came out too quick.
“Oh my God. You’re from the gym.”
“Yeah.” His voice was lower than she had built in her head. Not unkind. Amused in a way that made her want to tuck her toes in and also not. “You were on the mat after class. Shoes off.”
“That was stretching.”
“Uh-huh.”
He did not move closer yet. He let the feet hang in the space between them. Kristen was suddenly, sharply aware of every detail he could see: the length of her toes, the height of the arches, the faint pink left from the studio floor, a shiny line of sun-sweat in the center of the left sole. She kept the book up like a shield that was doing nothing.
“This is going to sound worse than the stretching,” she said. “My husband has this thing. Fishing. I sit here with a book and… this. It’s stupid.”
“Doesn’t look stupid from here.”
He said it looking at her soles, not her face. The same look from the gym, only now there was no glass and no weight rack to pretend about. Kristen’s pulse sat in the arches. She almost texted Chris with one hand and did not, because she would have to take her eyes off the man to do it.
“You’re the one who was watching,” she said.
“You flexed.”
She had. She could not pretend she had not. The admission sat in the warm air with the pretzel smell and a cart rattling somewhere behind him.
“I didn’t think you’d be at the mall.”
“I wasn’t, until I was.” He tipped his chin at her feet. “You leaving those out for anybody, or was the gym a specific invitation?”
Kristen’s mouth went dry. The family-photograph version of her had a speech about boundaries and jokes and how this was just airing out after errands. The other version — the one with the online following and the nightstand drawer and the pillow confession about a good-looking Black guy — heard the question and did not pull her feet in.
“Anybody was the official story,” she said. “The gym is why I didn’t put the sneakers back on when I saw you walking over.”
His mouth moved. Almost a smile. He stepped in half a pace, still not touching, close enough now that if she pointed her toes she would brush denim.
“Can I?”
Two words. Kristen’s laugh this time was smaller, helpless at the edges. She glanced at the lot. A couple with bags was a row away, not looking. A car door slammed. The world was still a Saturday mall. Her bare feet were still out the window of her own car, long toes, high arches, notoriously ticklish in a way this man did not know yet and Chris wanted him to find out.
She nodded once.
He touched the left sole with two fingers.
Not a grab. A test. Pads of his fingers in the soft center of the arch, light, as if he were checking temperature. Kristen’s whole foot jerked. The book slid. A sound came out of her that she swallowed halfway, too high for a parking lot. His eyes flicked from the sole to her face and the almost-smile became real, because he had felt the jerk and he understood it immediately.
“Ticklish.”
“Don’t—” She laughed, already, the ugly early laugh, and did not pull the foot away. “Don’t start that here. There are people.”
He did not start that, not fully. He left the two fingers where they were and drew a slow line from the center of the arch toward the ball of her foot, and her toes clenched so hard the knuckles went pale. She thrashed as much as a woman with her heels hooked on a car door could thrash. The other foot kicked air. She clapped her free hand over her mouth and still made a noise into her palm.
He took his fingers off.
The absence was almost worse. Kristen lay back against the seat with her feet still hanging, chest going, paperback crushed to her stomach, and looked at him like she had not decided whether to be angry. She was not angry. She was bright-hot and ridiculous and wet-eyed from one line on one arch in a mall lot.
“Okay,” she said. “Okay. You felt that.”
“I felt that.”
“My husband is going to lose his mind.”
“He know you’re out here?”
“He sent me out here.” She heard how that sounded and did not clean it up. “He’s had this… interest. Sharing them. With another foot person. I told him if it was ever anyone it would look like—” She stopped, because finishing that sentence in a parking lot at a man she knew from a gym was a lot. “You. Someone like you. We joked about it. Then I saw you looking this morning and he told me to come fish.”
The man glanced at her hanging feet again, then at the lot, then back at her. He was still close. He had not put his hands in his pockets. He looked like he wanted the other sole and was choosing not to take it in front of the pretzel shop.
“You want to stay out here and hope nobody from preschool walks by,” he said, “or you want to go somewhere those get a proper look?”
Kristen’s phone buzzed on the console. She knew it was Chris without looking. She picked it up one-handed.
Anyone?
She typed with her thumb, the other hand still holding the ruined page, her left sole still tingling where two fingers had been.
Him. Gym guy. He touched one. I jumped. He knows they’re ticklish now.
The three dots came and went.
Invite him. If you’re comfortable. You said knowing him made it different.
She stared at the text. She stared at her own feet in the window, long toes, sun on the arches, the one sole already pinker than the other. She stared at the man who had watched her on a mat and then found her in a lot like the net had actually worked.
“What’s your name?” she asked.
“Marcus.”
It suited the face she had already had in her head. She gave him hers, first name only, the way you did when the rest of the biography — three kids, former teacher, the pink thing in the drawer — did not belong in a first conversation over a car door.
“Marcus. My husband says if I’m comfortable I should invite you somewhere less… mall.”
“Are you comfortable?”
She looked at her feet instead of his face. That was easier. They were still out. She had not pulled them in when he asked. She had not pulled them in when he touched. The stretch on the mat had been a flex. This was a door.
“More than I would be if you were some random,” she said. “That’s the true part. The rest of me is a mom who is going to have to pick up kids at three and pretend this didn’t happen. So if we do more, it has to be now, and it can’t be here, because I will scream if you do that line again and I do not want to explain that to security.”
Marcus’s laugh was quiet. He looked at her soles one more time, thorough, like he was taking a last public inventory — length of toes, height of arch, the shine in the center, the way the left one still twitched when his shadow moved across it.
“I have a place twenty minutes from here,” he said. “Or you name a park with no playground on it. Your call. I’m not following you home unless you want that problem.”
“Not home.” The word came out fast. Home had shin guards in the hall and recital notes on the fridge. “Your place. I text him the address. That’s the deal. And it’s feet. That’s what he asked for. That’s what you were looking at. I’m not—” She stopped again, because the sentence about her body and her toys and the break she might someday offer to get someone off her soles was a Chapter she was not in yet. “It’s feet.”
“Feet,” he said. “I can live on feet.”
He said it looking at them, and the way he said live made her toes curl without anyone touching them.
Kristen pulled her heels off the frame. The lot air felt colder the second her soles left it. She sat in the car with her bare feet on the mat and the book in her lap and typed Chris the address Marcus recited, plus twenty minutes. He knows the deal. I’ll call if I want out.
Chris sent back a single word.
Go.
She started the engine. Marcus stepped back from the door. For a second they were just two people in a mall lot on Saturday, one of them a woman who still had a bent paperback and a ponytail, the other a man who had now felt how hard her arch jumped under two fingers.
“Don’t be gentle when we get there just because there were people here,” she said, and then she heard herself, thirty-six, three kids, and clapped her mouth shut on a grin that was half horror. “I mean. They’re really ticklish. You’re going to find out anyway. I’m just saying I know what I walked into.”
Marcus looked at her feet on the pedals, then at her face.
“I was not planning on gentle,” he said.
She pulled out of the space with her window still down and the sun still on her ankles and the ghost of his fingers still in the center of her left arch. In the rearview he was walking to a dark car two rows over. The net had worked. The gym had followed her into the lot. The woman in the family photographs was driving toward a stranger’s address with her sneakers on the passenger floor and her husband’s permission in her pocket, and her feet — long toes, high arches, notoriously, stupidly ticklish — were already braced for the moment there would be no window and no book and no mall to hide the sound.
She did not pull out.
The engine was on. The address was in the phone. Chris’s Go was still lit on the screen. Marcus was a dark car two rows back, and the smart thing — the mom thing, the three-o’clock-pickup thing — was to roll the window up and drive.
Kristen sat with her bare feet on the pedals and the paperback in the passenger footwell and felt the left arch still jumping where two fingers had been. The lot went on being a lot. Carts. Sun. A kid crying at a minivan. She put the car in park again, killed the engine, and hung both feet back out the window before she could talk herself out of it.
It was a worse idea the second time. That was why she did it.
Marcus saw the feet come back out. He walked over without the hesitation of a first approach. He stopped at the same yard of lane and looked at what she had put back on offer: long toes, high arches, the left sole already a little pinker than the right, both of them in the sun like she had decided the mall was allowed to watch.
“Changed your mind about leaving?” he asked.
“Changed my mind about giving you only two fingers in a parking lot.” She heard how that sounded and laughed into it, hot-faced. “Chris is going to read the text log and think I lost my mind. I probably have. You can—” She glanced at a couple passing with bags, two rows over, not looking. “You can do it properly. If someone walks by I will die. That’s the risk. I’m leaving them out anyway.”
Marcus looked at the lot, then at her soles, then at her face.
“Say stop and I stop,” he said. “Say quiet and I go lighter. I’m not trying to get you a security escort.”
“Just don’t be gentle,” she said, for the second time that hour, and then she put the back of her wrist in her teeth because the woman in the family photographs did not say things like that with her feet hanging out of a Honda.
He took the left foot in both hands.
Not two fingers. The whole sole. His palm under the heel, thumbs already finding the high arch, the long toes trapped loosely so she could kick and not go anywhere. Kristen’s body tried to fold forward in the seat. A sound came out of her, high and stupid, and she bit it in half.
He started in the center.
That was the worst place. Chris knew it. She knew it. Marcus found it in three seconds of looking at how the skin creased and went to work like he had been handed a map. Thumbs pressing up into the softest part of the arch, then sliding toward the ball, then back, a slow grind that was not a massage. Kristen thrashed. The car door took her heel. Her other foot kicked the mirror frame and made it shudder. She laughed into her wrist, then into the open air, then clapped her own hand over her mouth while her eyes watered.
A woman with a Target bag crossed the lane behind him. Kristen saw her over Marcus’s shoulder, saw the woman’s glance tick off the hanging feet and the man holding them and then flick away, polite, refusing the picture. The refusal made it worse. They were public and not public. Her sole was in a stranger-from-the-gym’s hands and the world had decided not to see it.
“People,” she got out.
“I see them.” He did not let go. He changed texture instead of pressure: the pads of his fingers skating the same center he had just ground, light, fast, the flutter that turned her laugh into something she could not swallow. Her toes splayed. They clenched. They splayed again. The long toes he had watched on the mat were doing the whole show against his knuckles.
“Ticklish doesn’t cover it,” he said, almost to the foot. “You jump if I think about moving.”
“Don’t narrate—” She broke off into a shriek she chopped short, because a dad and two kids were coming out of the crosswalk three spaces down. Marcus froze the motion without releasing the foot. Kristen hung there, sole in his hands, chest heaving, smiling a bright fake smile at nobody, until the kids were past the carts. Then his thumb sank back into the arch and she folded again, laughing for real, ugly and wet.
Her phone buzzed on the dash.
She had to peel one hand off her mouth to grab it. Marcus did not pause. He switched to the line under her toes — the thin, vicious strip that made her kick the door — while she tried to see the screen through tears.
Chris: You went quiet. Still there?
She typed with her thumb, misspelling half of it.
Window. He’s got the left one. I can’t be quiet. Lot is full. I’m dying.
Chris: Good dying or out dying?
She looked at her own foot in Marcus’s hands. The sole was pink now, shiny in the sun, the arch flexing against his thumbs like it was trying to hide inside itself. She was thirty-six. She had a recital next weekend. She was going to have to pick children up at three and talk about cake.
Good. Don’t stop him. I’m an idiot.
Chris: Ask him for the other one. Then go to the address. I want the private version too.
Marcus had already taken the other one.
He stacked them.
Both of her bare feet in his grip, heels together, arches offered to the lane, long toes pointing at his chest. The position made her feel more hung-out than before, more like the fishing joke had stopped being a joke. He raked both centers at once with his fingertips and Kristen made a noise that was not appropriate for a mall. She thrashed so hard the seatbelt buckle dug into her hip. Her ponytail stuck to her mouth. She spat it out and laughed and tried to say quiet and said fuck instead, whispered, vicious, helpless.
“Under the toes,” he said, and did it.
Both sets. The flutter. No mercy in a public place except the mercy of not doing it louder. Kristen’s head tipped back against the rest. She could see sky and a sliver of a light pole and the idea of a security golf cart that was not there yet. Her feet tried to clap together. He did not let them. He kept the soles open and worked the arches in small cruel circles until she was shaking in the seat, the paperback on the floor, the phone clutched to her collarbone, Chris’s last text glowing against her skin.
A man on a phone walked within a row. He looked. He looked longer than the Target woman. Marcus did not turn. He eased the flutter into a slow press, which was not kindness; the slow press in the center of both arches made Kristen sob-laugh into her teeth and curl forward until her forehead almost hit the wheel.
“Okay,” she gasped. “Okay—okay—window’s done. Window’s done. I will scream. I will actually scream and then I will have to invent a wasp.”
Marcus slowed. He did not drop her feet. He held them, thumbs resting in the wet centers, and looked at what he had done: two wrecked soles, pink, ticking with leftover nerves, long toes still clenched. He looked like he had at the gym, only now he had data. He knew the map.
“Address still good?” he asked.
“Address is good.” She pulled her feet in. The instant they left his hands they felt huge, loud, too sensitive for the pedals. She sat in the car with her knees up and her soles on the seat edge and wiped her face with the hem of the rec-league shirt. “You were not gentle.”
“You told me twice.”
“I’m going to tell my husband you stacked them in a parking lot.”
“Tell him they jumped the same way on both sides.” Marcus stepped back from the door, glanced once more at her feet on the seat, and tipped his head toward his car. “Follow me. If you change your mind at a light, change your mind. I’ll see the Honda turn off.”
She did not change her mind at a light.
She drove with the window still cracked and the air hitting the damp of her arches every time she shifted her foot on the pedal. The mall shrank in the mirror. The book stayed on the floor. Her phone buzzed through a string of Chris, and she answered at a red light with one thumb.
Leaving the lot. He stacked them. I almost screamed. People saw and pretended not to. On the way to his. Feet only. I’ll text when I’m in the door.
Chris: How bad?
She looked at her own left sole against the pedal. The center was still pink. She could feel every groove of the rubber.
Worse than you. Different than you. He found the middle in three seconds. I am in so much trouble.
Chris: Good. Don’t you dare put socks on before you get there.
She laughed at the light, a leftover, shaky sound, and the car behind her honked. She went. Twenty minutes of ordinary road. Strip plazas. A grocery she used on Tuesdays. The double life riding with her in the cabin: shin guards at home, a man from the gym ahead in a dark car, her notoriously ticklish feet bare on the pedals because her husband had told her not to cover them.
Marcus’s place was a ground-floor unit off a quiet lot, no playground, no preschool decal in any window. She parked. She sat for ten seconds with her hands on the wheel and her soles on the mat and the mom voice listing every reason to start the engine again. Then she picked up the phone.
Here. Going in. If I text the word recital, call me and I’ll come home.
Chris: Understood. Tell me how loud it is when it isn’t a mall.
Kristen got out barefoot. The asphalt was rough. She took the sneakers in one hand and the phone in the other and did not put the sneakers on. Marcus was already at his door. He looked at her bare feet on his walkway, at the long toes and the sun-pink arches and the way she walked like the ground was too much after the window, and he held the door.
She stepped through.
Behind her the Saturday lot went on being ordinary. Ahead of her there was no window to stuff a laugh into, and no Target bag to make him freeze, and no book to hide her face. Just the feet she had fished with, and a man who already knew they jumped if he thought about moving, and a husband two suburbs over waiting for a report on how loud it got when the only risk left was how ticklish she actually was.
His place was smaller than she had pictured and cleaner than she had feared. Blinds half-drawn. A couch that had seen use. No photographs of children on the fridge, which helped. Kristen stood on his mat just inside the door with her sneakers in one hand and her phone in the other and her bare feet on someone else’s floor, and the first thing she said was not about the feet.
“I only came because I know your face.”
Marcus closed the door. He did not lock it in a way that made a show of locking it. He looked at her the way he had in the lot, then at the long toes on his mat.
“Gym,” he said. “Not a guy from a van. I got it.”
“If you had been a stranger at that window I would have pulled them in and driven to Target like a coward.” She set the sneakers down. She set the phone on his counter, face-up, Chris’s thread still open. “I’m a mom. I’m supposed to be at a birthday party circuit, not in a ground-floor unit with my shoes off. Knowing you from the weights is the only reason this doesn’t feel like I lost my mind in a parking lot.”
“You did lose your mind in a parking lot,” he said. “You just recognized the person you lost it with.”
That pulled a laugh out of her that was still shaky from the window. He pointed at the couch. She sat. The cushion dipped. She tucked one foot under her by habit and then, because the habit was a lie, she put both soles on the edge of the coffee table instead, offered without being asked. Long toes. High arches. The left one still pinker from the lot. The centers still too awake.
“Feet,” she said. “That was the deal I texted him. He knows where I am. If I say recital, this ends.”
“Recital,” Marcus repeated, like he was putting the word in a pocket. “All right.”
He sat on the table facing her, her soles between them, and took both feet in his hands with none of the public caution. No Target bags. No kids in a crosswalk. The thumbs went straight to the centers of the arches and pressed.
Kristen folded.
The sound that came out of her had no mall in it. It was the real one, the one she stuffed into pillows at home when Chris forgot to be careful. She thrashed back into the couch. Her knees tried to snap shut and his hips were already there, keeping her open. He worked both arches at once, grinding, then fluttering, then grinding again, and he watched her feet while he did it the same way he had watched them through studio glass — like they were the whole point of the room.
“Worse than the window,” she got out, laughing already, wet-eyed already. “That’s not fair. You already mapped them.”
“You gave me a map in a Honda.” He raked the line under her toes and her long toes splayed so hard they shook. “Gym was the looking. Lot was the test. This is the part your husband asked for.”
She should have hated that he brought Chris into it. She did not. The knowing — gym face, husband’s permission, her own mouth saying a good-looking Black guy into a pillow months ago — was the only reason she kept her soles on the table instead of kicking free and going for the door.
He was not gentle.
He had told her he would not be. He used his nails in the high arches until she shrieked and clapped a hand over her own mouth and then took the hand away because there was no neighbor with a slushie here, only blinds and a couch and a man who was enjoying the way her feet jumped. He stacked them the way he had at the car and raked both soles from heel to toe in one long stroke. Kristen’s whole body jackknifed. She laughed until she hiccupped. She tried to say wait and said his name instead, first-name familiar, gym-familiar, which made it worse and better.
“Marcus—Jesus—”
He hooked her ankles under one arm the way he had wanted to in the lot and went after the inner edges, the thin skin along the arches that made her kick Chris in bed. She kicked him. He took it and did not stop. The soles pinked. They shone. The long toes clenched and opened and clenched. She was thirty-six and a former teacher and a woman who packed birthday bags, and she was thrashing on a stranger-who-was-not-a-stranger’s couch with her rec-league shirt rucked up and her ponytail in her mouth.
He slowed only to change attack.
Knuckles in the centers. Then one fingertip writing the same circle in the worst spot on the left foot until she was sobbing laughter into the cushion. Then the right foot the same way, thorough, patient, mean. He looked satisfied. Not rushed. A man who had watched those feet on a mat and waited through a mall and now had them.
Kristen’s phone lit on the counter. She could not reach it. Marcus glanced at the screen without taking both hands off her.
“He says how loud.”
“Tell him—” She broke off into a scream-laugh when his nail found the left heel, the spot she hated. “Tell him I can’t text. Tell him I know your face and I’m still an idiot.”
Marcus did not text for her. He went back to the stacked soles and the flutter under both sets of toes until she was shaking too hard to make words. Then he eased off just enough that she could breathe, thumbs resting in the wet centers, her feet ticking in his grip.
“Comfortable?” he asked.
It was a rotten question. She was wrecked. She was barefoot in a ground-floor unit on a Saturday with kids due at three. She was also, treacherously, still on the table.
“I’m comfortable that you’re not a random,” she said, hoarse. “I’m not comfortable about my feet. They’re — they’re worse when I can’t pretend it’s a joke at a window.”
“You want a break.”
She did. The client-beat she had almost offered Chris in a different life sat on her tongue: take something else, just get off the soles. She swallowed it. Not yet. Feet was the deal. Feet was what Chris had sent her fishing for.
“A minute,” she said. “Then you can ruin them again. I know what I walked into. I said that in the lot. I’m saying it here because I know you from the gym and that is the only reason I haven’t used the recital word.”
Marcus nodded once. He set her feet down on the table and let them twitch in the air like they did not believe they were free. Kristen stared at her own soles. Pink. Shiny. Long toes still half-clenched. The arches looked like they belonged to someone who posted photos for strangers and then went to a dance recital like the photos were a different woman.
She laughed, wrecked and goofy, the streak that did not match the family pictures.
“He’s going to want every second of this,” she said, meaning Chris. “The stack. The heel. How I said your name. How I only stayed because I knew your face.”
“He can have the report.” Marcus’s hands hovered over her arches again, not touching yet. “Minute’s up when you put them back in my hands. You don’t have to say anything. Just give them to me.”
Kristen looked at the door. She looked at the phone. She looked at the man from the weights who had followed a pair of bare feet from a studio to a mall to a couch.
She put her feet back in his hands.
He started in the centers without warming up, and the sound she made had no window left to hide in, and she did not say recital, because knowing him was still enough, and because her husband had asked for this exact trouble, and because the wholesome woman in the photographs had never been the whole story.
The second wave on the couch did not have a mall in it and did not have a minute in it either.
Marcus took the feet she had put back in his hands and went at the centers like the pause had been a courtesy he was done paying. Thumbs grinding both high arches. Fingers raking the line under the long toes. The stacked stroke from heel to ball that made her jackknife. Kristen laughed until her stomach cramped. She kicked him and hit nothing that mattered. The rec-league shirt was rucked under her breasts. Her ponytail had come loose. She was thirty-six and a mother of three and she could hear her own voice filling a ground-floor unit on a Saturday like it belonged to someone who did not pack recital snacks.
“Wait—” It was not recital. Recital was the door. This was something else. “Marcus. Wait. I can’t— I can’t do another ten minutes of just that. I’ll throw up. I’m not joking.”
He slowed. He did not let go. His thumbs stayed in the wet centers of her soles, a threat dressed as a rest. Her feet ticked against his palms. She hated how small they looked there. She hated how much Chris was going to like the report.
“You want a break from these,” Marcus said.
“Yes.”
“Breaks cost.”
Kristen shut her eyes. The beat she had almost told her husband to put in a story — offer the rest of her to get someone off her feet — was sitting in her mouth with gym-salt and parking-lot air. The wholesome photograph-woman would have used the safe word and driven to the birthday party. The other woman, the one with a following for her arches and a pink thing in a nightstand at home, opened her eyes.
“What does it cost?”
“You say it.” He drew one fingertip down the left arch, light, and she jerked so hard the couch moved. “Not a hint. You tell me what you’re offering so I get off these long toes for a while.”
She laughed, wrecked and ugly, because of course he would make her say it. Of course the man who had watched her on a mat would not let the mom-voice do the dirty work in mime.
“You can have the rest of me,” she said. It came out flat first, then hotter when his fingertip paused on the worst spot and she had to push the rest past a gasp. “Not just the feet. Mouth. Hands. You can fuck me. You can— God, you can do whatever gets your hands off my soles for five minutes before I start crying for real. That’s the offer. I’m a married suburban idiot who went fishing and I am asking you to use something that isn’t my arches.”
Marcus looked at her face, then at the feet in his hands, then at the phone on the counter.
“He know that part?”
“He knows I have a wild streak he likes to pretend he invented.” She swallowed. “He knows about the drawer at home. He doesn’t know I’m saying this in your living room. I’ll tell him. After. If you stop tickling long enough for me to have a brain.”
Marcus set her left foot down.
Only the left.
The right one he kept, and he punished it while he thought, a slow cruel circle in the center of the arch that made her sob-laugh and clutch the cushion. Then he set that one down too. The absence was a hole. Her soles twitched on the table, pink, shiny, long toes still half-clenched, waiting for a hit that did not come.
“Shirt off,” he said. “You offered a body. I want to see the rest of the woman from the gym.”
Kristen pulled the rec-league shirt over her head. Sports bra after. The air in the unit hit skin that usually only saw a locked bathroom and a husband. She was not a magazine. She was thirty-six and three pregnancies and athletic in a practical way, and she watched his eyes go from her feet to her mouth to her chest and back to her feet like he might change his mind and stack them again.
He did not stack them.
He hooked his fingers in the waist of the capris and she lifted her hips and let him take those too, and the underwear with them, until she was on his couch with nothing on but the ponytail falling down and the flush from laughing. The contrast landed in her like a slap she had asked for: birthday bags, classroom voice, bare on a gym-guy’s couch because her arches had broken her.
“You can still say recital,” he said.
“I’m not saying recital.”
He kissed her mouth first, which she had not expected. It was not tender. It was a man tasting the laugh still on her teeth. Then his mouth went down. Throat. The sports-bra line that wasn’t there anymore. He sucked a nipple and she made a sound that was not a tickle-sound and her traitorous foot kicked the table anyway. He caught the foot without looking, held it still, and kept his mouth on her breast until her head tipped back.
“That’s not off the soles,” she gasped. “That’s you holding one.”
“Insurance.” He bit, light, and she arched. “I get off them when I’m inside you. Not before.”
He opened his jeans with the other hand. She watched because she had offered and because looking away would have been a lie. He was already hard. He shoved his pants down far enough and pulled her hips to the edge of the couch and set the head of him against her. She was wet. The tickling had done that as much as the mouth. The fishing had done that. Chris’s Go had done that. She was a mom with a secret following and she was slick for the man who had mapped her feet in a Honda.
He pushed in.
Kristen’s laugh broke into a groan. He filled her in one slow shove that made her hands fist in the cushion, and the foot he was still holding jerked in his grip like it wanted the old torture back and also never wanted it again. He did not tickle that sole. He held it open, thumb in the arch, a reminder, and fucked her with deep unhurried strokes that had nothing to do with a mall window.
“This is the break,” he said against her mouth. “You earned it by asking. You keep earning it by taking it.”
She took it. She was loud. The unit had blinds and no playground and she still heard herself and thought of the woman in the family photographs and laughed once, helpless, at the gap. He found an angle that made her swear. He kept the one foot hostage, thumb pressing the center of the arch in time with his hips, not a full attack, a metronome of I could. Every time she got close he pressed harder into the sole and the laugh mixed into the moan and she could not tell which one she was doing.
“Chris is going to want this part,” she said, wrecked. “He’s going to want that I bought a break with my—”
Marcus thrust and the sentence died. He let go of the foot.
Both hands on her hips. No insurance. The soles were free on the air, twitching, ignored, and the ignoring was almost as filthy as the flutter had been. He fucked her like the feet had been the door and this was the room. Kristen came first, surprised by it, a tight helpless clench that pulled a sound out of her she would have to describe later whether she wanted to or not. He did not stop. He dragged her through it until she was shaking and then he pulled out and came on her stomach with a curse, one hand braced on the couch, the other — traitor — catching her right ankle so her sole was open in his peripheral vision the whole time.
For a few seconds there was only breathing.
Kristen stared at the ceiling. Sweat at her hairline. Come on her belly. Her feet still up on the table edge like they had not gotten the message that the deal had changed. The pink toy at home felt like a joke compared to the fact of him. The gym felt like a year ago. It had been four hours.
Marcus ran one finger through the mess on her skin, then — because he was who he was — down to her left sole, and painted a wet streak across the arch.
She jerked. She laughed. She almost kicked him in the face.
“That’s not a break,” she said.
“Break’s over.” He smiled at the streak on her arch. “You offered a body to get me off these. I got off. They’re still the reason I walked up to a Honda.”
He licked the center of that sole.
Kristen screamed laughter and tried to twist away and his hands were already there, stacking her feet again, mouth on the arch he had marked, tongue in the worst spot, and the break she had earned was done. She thrashed. She was naked and loud and ticklish beyond sense, and he ate the laugh out of her feet like the sex had only been a pause between courses.
Her phone lit.
She could not reach it. She did not need to. She knew the text. How loud.
“Louder,” she told the ceiling, while Marcus’s tongue wrote a circle in her arch and her long toes clenched in his hair. “Tell him I paid. Tell him it didn’t last. Tell him I know his face and I still can’t get my feet back.”
Marcus did not stop to tell anyone anything. He held her stacked soles to his mouth and tickled them with his tongue until she was crying real tears of laughter, naked on a gym-guy’s couch, the wholesome day still waiting out there with cake and shin guards, and the wild streak finally, finally matching the rest of the room.
When he finally lifted his head her arches were shining and her voice was gone and the break she had bought was a story she was going to have to take home in her mouth and give to her husband in order.
“Socks,” she whispered, not meaning it.
“Not yet,” Marcus said, and put two fingers back in the center of her left arch just to watch her jump. “You still have until three. Recital’s a word. Use it or give me the feet.”
Kristen looked at her own wrecked soles.
She gave him the feet.
She put the capris back on inside out the first time and had to laugh at herself, wrecked and goofy, standing on his mat with come wiped off her stomach with a gym towel and her soles still ticking like they had a pulse of their own. The sports bra went on crooked. The rec-league shirt smelled like his couch. She did not ask for a shower. A shower would have made her late and would have washed off the report.
Marcus watched her dress from the table. He looked at her feet until the sneakers went over them, and even then he looked at the canvas like he could see the arches through it.
“Three o’clock,” she said.
“I remember.”
“If I come back to the gym I will stretch on the other side of the room.”
“No you won’t.”
She almost smiled. She picked up the phone. Chris had sent three messages she had not been able to answer. She typed in the doorway, thumbs clumsy.
On the way home. Intact. No recital. I have to tell you in person or I will crash the car.
The reply was already waiting when she hit the first light.
Kids get dropped at 3:10. You’ve got a window. Start talking when you park.
She drove barefoot inside the sneakers, no socks, because he had told her not to put socks on before Marcus’s and putting them on after felt like cheating. Every time she pressed the pedal the left arch lit up where a tongue had been. She thought about cake and shin guards and the word stacked. She thought about the sentence she had said out loud to get a break and how short the break had been. She thought about the woman in the family photographs and could not find her in the Honda for a full mile.
The driveway was ordinary. A sprinkler. A neighbor’s bin. Chris opened the door before she got the key out.
He looked at her face first. Then at the sneakers. Then at the fact that she had not put her hair back up.
“Inside,” he said.
The house was still the house. Recital notice on the fridge. Someone’s water bottle on its side. The quiet before 3:10. Kristen toed the sneakers off on the same kitchen tile where she had flexed for him that morning and her bare feet looked like evidence. Pink centers. A faint shine still in the left arch if you knew to look. Long toes that curled when his eyes landed on them.
Chris did not touch them yet.
“Tell me,” he said.
She told him from the mat.
The lot first, because the lot was the joke they had built. The book she had not read. The feet out the window. Marcus walking up like the gym had followed her. Two fingers in the left arch. The jump. The Target woman who had looked away. The stack at the window, both soles in the sun, the dad with two kids she had had to fake-smile past while she died. The texts. His Go.
Chris’s mouth had gone loose in the way it did when the interest in him got ahead of his face. He was hard in his jeans and not hiding it. She kept talking because if she stopped she would start editing, and he had not asked for an edited version.
“His place was a ground floor. I said I only went because I knew his face. That’s true. If he’d been a random I would have pulled them in and bought pretzels.” She swallowed. “He sat me on the couch and put my feet on the table and he was not gentle. He already had the map from the Honda. Centers. Under the toes. Heels. He stacked them again. I said his name. I could not text you. I told him to tell you I was an idiot.”
“How loud,” Chris said. Not a question.
“Loud. No window to hide it. I laughed until I hiccupped. I kicked him. He did not care.” Her face was hot. The mom-voice wanted to tidy this into a cute story. She did not let it. “Then I asked for a break.”
Chris went very still.
“I offered the rest of me,” she said. “He made me say it. Not a hint. Mouth, hands, he could fuck me, whatever got him off my soles for five minutes. I said I was a married suburban idiot who went fishing. I said I would tell you after. I’m telling you.”
The kitchen clock moved. 2:51. She kept going, because the silence was going to make her lie by omission and she was already in too far for omission.
“Shirt off. Everything off. He held one foot while he was inside me like insurance. Thumb in the arch on the beat. I came like that. He came on my stomach. Then he wiped it on my sole and licked it off and the break was over.” She laughed once, helpless, at her own ceiling. “He went back to my feet with his mouth. I gave them to him again. I did not say recital. I had until three and I gave him the feet.”
Chris let out a breath that was almost a laugh and almost not. He crouched, the same crouch from the morning, and he looked at her soles on their tile like he was reading a language only the two of them spoke. He touched the left arch with one finger, light, and she jerked hard enough to catch the counter.
“That’s the spot,” he said.
“That’s the spot.”
“He found it in three seconds.”
“He found it in three seconds.”
Chris put his mouth where his finger had been, just a press, not a full attack, and Kristen laughed into her fist because her body did not know the difference between a husband on kitchen tile and a gym guy on a couch. He stopped. He stayed crouched. His voice came out rough.
“You liked that he knew you from the weights.”
“Yes.”
“You liked that I sent you.”
“Yes.”
“You liked paying for the break and not getting to keep it.”
She shut her eyes. The honest answer was the wild-streak answer. “Yes.”
2:56. A car door slammed somewhere on the street and both of them flinched, then it was the wrong house. Chris stood. He kissed her mouth and tasted, she knew, everything she had just said. His hand stayed off her feet. The off was loud.
“Socks,” he said. “Kids. You can be the other woman again after bath time.”
She put socks on. Ankle socks, white, the kind that went with the photographs. The arches disappeared. The long toes disappeared. She scraped her hair into a ponytail that almost held. She washed her face. She looked like Saturday pickup. She did not feel like Saturday pickup. The left sole still had a ghost of a tongue in it every time she flexed inside the sock.
The minivan arrived at 3:09. Chaos returned on schedule. Cupcakes. A lost shoe that was not hers. A story about a piñata she only half heard. Chris took bags. She kissed hair that was not Marcus’s and packed water bottles and was the woman on the fridge magnet for two hours without a crack showing, except once, when she sat on the couch during a cartoon and Chris looked at her socked feet and she had to get up and go to the kitchen so she would not laugh in front of a talking animal.
Bath time. Stories. Lights out.
The house went dim and expensive with quiet. Kristen stood in their bedroom and took the socks off like she was taking off a costume. Chris was already on the edge of the bed. She put her bare feet in his lap before he asked.
“Again,” he said. “Slower. The stack at the window.”
She gave it to him slower. The Target bag. The fake smile. The way Marcus had frozen the flutter when the dad walked by and then put the thumb back the second the kids were past. She gave him the couch. The minute that had not been a minute. The sentence she had to say to buy the break. The insurance-thumb. The lick. The second yes, the one where she put her feet back in Marcus’s hands with her own body still wet from him.
Chris was touching her while she talked. Not tickling, not at first. Holding the arches, tracing the long toes, mapping the pink that had faded and was still, if you knew, there. When she got to the lick he did tickle, sudden, two fingers in the center of the left foot, and she laughed into a pillow the way she had in Tampa years ago, except now the laugh had a mall and a gym and another man’s name in it.
“Fishing again?” he asked, when she could breathe.
Kristen stared at the ceiling. Recital next weekend. Grocery list on her phone. A man named Marcus who would be at the weights on Tuesday.
“Not tomorrow,” she said. “I’m not a maniac.” She turned her head on the pillow and looked at her husband, at the interest in his face that had never been anger, at the feet in his lap that had been out a window for him. “Another Saturday. Kids at a party. I’ll stretch at the gym. If he’s looking I won’t pull them in. If you tell me to roll the window down I will roll the window down.”
“And if he wants more than feet.”
She thought about the cost. She thought about saying it out loud. She thought about the photographs and the drawer and the fact that the wholesome version had never been the whole story.
“Then I text you,” she said. “And I make him hear me say it. And I come home and I sit on this bed and I tell you how loud it was when there wasn’t a mall.”
Chris kissed the high arch of her right foot, careful, almost polite, which somehow wrecked her more than Marcus’s nails. She flexed against his mouth. Long toes. Pronounced arch. Notoriously, stupidly ticklish. A suburban mom with a secret that now had a name and an address and a husband who wanted the next report more than he wanted the lie that fishing had been a one-time joke.
“Tuesday,” Chris said against her sole. “Stretch where he can see.”
“Tuesday,” she said.
In the dark her phone lit once on the nightstand. She did not check it. She already knew it would either be nothing or a gym schedule. She left the socks off. She left the window of the next Saturday open in the room with them. She fell asleep with her feet in her husband’s hands and the ghost of another man’s thumbs still in the centers, and the woman in the family photographs slept too, because she had always been real — she had just never been the entire story.
FOR COMMISSIONS, DM ON DEVIANTART: https://www.deviantart.com/natorlstudio
