TOUGH CALL, but...
After careful consideration, I'd have to go with Jessica.
Carmen has a nicer body overall, and there's no contest in the leg dept. I also think she has the prettier feet of the two. But Jessica has a prettier face. That helped my decision. I like seeing a really pretty face contorted with helpless laughter. Combine that with that really enticing & infectious giggle she has (anyone who's heard it knows what I mean) and I have to give her the nod. I've seen that infamous Howard Stern session with Carmen and she didn't seem like much of a laugher. Oh, she definitely had strong reactions, but I don't remember hearing much from her despite her obvious sensitivity. For me, the laugh is everything. What good is having a really ticklish 'lee when you can't hear those oh-so-sweet sounds? With Jessica, who I understand is quite ticklish herself, I can imagine the rewards being more gratifying in the audible laughter department.
Anybody concur?