Not to sound like a bitch, but the 1800s America setting might be harder for roleplaying because it's pretty much only familiar to Americans, and unlike medieval fantasy there are very few mainstream sources (movies, TV shows, etc) set in that era where non-Americans can get inspiration from. It's okay if you are only appealing to the same group who participated in Aygomen Glenn, but I imagine that getting more players to join in won't be easy.
On top of that... and I apologise if it seems like I'm insulting you, because I'm not... the story about the circus, although with amazing quality and detail, doesn't really grab the attention of someone who comes here for a fetish. Then again, if you manage to find players who get into it, that's great. I can't speak for everyone on this site, I'm just letting you know what I think.
To be entirely honest, i do kind'a see where Cassandra is coming from. I still have mixed feelings about the world of the game and the use of a circus for the game setting. I'm not saying they are bad ideas, just that personally, i'm having a difficult time getting into the swing of it, which can be bad for a player, and particulerly bad if i'm going to be co-gming. I still need to sit down and give the previous game a thorough read, and that might change my views.