As a foot fetishist, this is a difficult question to answer, but if I HAD to pick, I'd say a drop dead gorgeous person with hideous feet, for this reason: Imagine if the girl and I hit it off, and we had to have each other for sex. While I love feet, I could stand kissing a pair of not nice feet every once in a while, but would rather have life and a full sex life with a person who is beautiful. I've always said on here that I feel in my personal opinion that Britney Spears has hideous feet, and as a foot fetishist, for feet alone, she would probably be about the last hot looking star whose feet I would want to worship. However, if I could have Miss Brit for a full sex life, I'd take her in a minute because I find her attractive otherwise.
So, my choice is a drop dead gorgeous person with hideous feet, if I had to pick in said situation.
Mitch