I'd hate to be AmishTickler right now! Whichever one he says is right, the other three are going to claim shenanigans and say he could have said ANY vitamin!
Talk about "breaking Amish"!

He usually has lube on his hands.....

N? 😀
Solution: VITAMIN C?
He usually has lube on his hands.....

New game:Well, you're right...I could mess with everybody and just pick another vitamin. BUT I was actually thinking of VITAMIN C. I am an honest guy. 🙂 New game to Milagros!
Sorry, there is no P. 😀