Since I have my own theory about everyone being weird, in at least some way, I would probably think they're weird. Then think how I'm weird. Then I would remember my theory about everyone being weird. Hence, I would think the members of this forum weird, but not unnecessarily in a bad way.
And if that person happens to be a violation of my rule, then he/she is just boring, and yet in a way still weird in his/her own way (being an exception to my rule). If I were an exception to my theory/rule, then I probably wouldn't have thought of my theory to begin with.
If that were the case, (a boring person with no oddities at all) then it all depends on how accepting that particular person is. Personally, I think I would think something along the lines of, "as long as it isn't degrading to other humans and consensual, whatever floats your boat."
So those are my two answers : If I fall under my theory, and if I don't.