Gee, you mean the producers who claim "we tricked X model into a situation she didn't understand, and made sure she didn't have a safeword so we could do whatever we wanted while she panicked!" are full of it? 🙄 Whoever would have imagined it.
(I've never understood why any producer would even want people to believe they did that kind of thing. Yes, it's selling a fantasy that appeals to some buyers - as a fantasy. But in reality it's a crime, and not exactly good for business.)
Honestly, this is a really thorny subject. I can't speak for anyone but myself and the other producers I've either interacted with or heard about via word of mouth.
If I had to speculate, I'd say that it's possible that in the good ol' days before things were more organized, it might have been, well, maybe not
common, but it certainly could have been easier to get away with. We had a lot of fly-by-night producers who would pop up, make a few videos, and then disappear. We have no idea why they disappeared, but we did hear the occasional snippet of wrongdoing about people, like that guy who would jerk off on underage models, or whatever. Given that the bulk of models back then were naive coeds, it stands to reason that even if a producer
was a creep, nobody would find out about it. For some reason, women are loathe to report assaults to the authorities. They'll pretty much tell anyone who'll listen
except the authorities, in my experience. (Disclaimer:
I am not judging. I recognize that there are a lot of valid reasons why this may occur.) As a result of this, unless the producer was part of her immediate social circle (highly unlikely), it would be basically impossible to damage their reputation on the scale that we see today.
That said... now? The bulk of models more established producers use come from the fetish modeling community. This community is hella organized; there are group chats, Twitter communities, even websites with "backstage" areas for the models to swap stories and give the yea or nay to working with people. People check references and are far more wary about GWCs than they used to be. Any wannabe who pulled some shady shit would most likely get blacklisted and
only be able to make do with hiring coeds, and the venues for doing that shrink more and more every year. No established producer would be able to sustainably hire fetish models if they were creeps.
Even so, I do occasionally hear bad stories about said established producers, but clearly they aren't bad enough that said producers don't continue to find talent.
But yes, as a general rule, you're correct. Attempting to do something like what you or the OP are suggesting is stupid-risky and very harmful to the long-term health of their studio. And given that the OP has asked some form of this question at least four or five times over the last two years, at this point I reckon it's less out of curiosity and more out of the hope that one of us will eventually slip up and admit that yes, we do abuse our models in whatever creepy controlling way that gets him off.
Can pretty much guarantee we don't, tho.