• If you would like to get your account Verified, read this thread
  • The TMF is sponsored by Clips4sale - By supporting them, you're supporting us.
  • >>> If you cannot get into your account email me at [email protected] <<<
    Don't forget to include your username

The Greatest Boxer of All Time?

My pick would be Muhammad Ali. Just my opinion, Tyson was good but Ali was great. I think the key word is 'boxing'. Ali actually 'boxed' his opponents while Tyson was a brute tank that usually ran through them. The end result which is the most important thing was a win for both. But for being a better 'boxer' Ali ran circles around Tyson. Far more of a complete package. just my 2 cents.
 
I agree that Ali is the greatest. I don't think anyone could beat the Ali that boxed before the Vietnam stuff. Even after he came back, he was still the greatest. And I would rate Jack Johnson as a very close second. If that fight could've occured it would have been very interesting. And it's funny that you would start this thread now because they actually are doing a list over at ESPN's website about the 50 greatest boxers. So far they've done 50-11 and the final 10 will be released tomorrow. Here is the link: http://sports.espn.go.com/sports/boxing/greatest/featureVideo?page=greatest4150
 
I'd say Mike Tyson. He was just so strong and his punches had so much power behind them.

I like Bernard Hopkins, Joe Frasier and George Foreman too.

I don't like Roy Jones Jr. or Floyed Mayweather, but they are obviously great as well.
 
Of the modern era of boxing, tyson dominated like no other, his only downfall was quality of opposition

For all time

Rocky Marciano and jack dempsey
 
I think Sugar Ray Robinson was the greatest. Joe Louis (my pick for second best :bubble: ) and Muhammad Ali are of the same mind. You could make a case for him being one of the greatest athletes this country ever produced. He lost only one of his first 125 fights as a professional. He avenged every loss he ever had (sometimes multiple times). He could fight you inside or out, was a great tactician, had speed, a killer jab, and tremendous power. His one aforementioned loss was to Jake LaMotta, who he went on to beat five or six times. The last time he won by tko- the only fighter to do this to LaMotta in nearly 100 fights. He also beat Joey Maxim, Henry Armstrong, Rocky Graziano, Carmen Basillo, Gene Fullmer, Kid Gavilan, and a bunch of other notable fighters that probably nobody here knows (including myself). Robinson suffered only one loss by knockout (tko) in his career, when he didn't answer the bell in extreme heat (he was ahead on the cards). He was everything you could want in a fighter.

I mean no disrespect towards anyones opinion- obviously everyone is entitled to their own. It's my belief that, in this sport, you have to at least take on the best fighters of your era in your weight class to be considered an elite fighter. Mike Tyson never did, so it ends up being idle speculation as to how good he was. Tim Witherspoon, George Foreman, Ray Mercer, Riddick Bowe, Michael Moorer- these were among the best heavyweights of his era and fighters whom he and his handlers clearly avoided. The quality opponents he faced, such as Evander Holyfield and Lennox Lewis, resulted in multiple losses. Holyfield, for my money, was the greatest heavyweight of his generation- taking on all comers and thus unifying the division. And he won a lot of those fights, too.

Joe Frazier was my favorite boxer, so I like most of your picks P[a]pi.
 
I was too young to follow Muhammad Ali's career, before and after Cassius Clay. plus I really wasn't into boxing as a kid. I did follow Mike Tyson's career, every pay-per-view match in the 80s and 90s including a live telecast in an arena.( I think this was the 91 second fight). Also saw the infamous "ear-biting" incident on HBO.

Who do I think the Greatest Boxer of all time is?.....


Muhammad Ali.


Drew
 
I agree that it was Tyson. There was a lot more to him than just punching power, he was technically very skilled when he was in his prime, he had a lot of speed and precision, and despite his reputation, he had a formidable defense as well.
 
I would've said Tyson, but when he lost to Buster Douglas, that ended that. Ali would've never lost to a guy like him

the greatest of all time
1. Muhammad Ali
1a. Joe Louis
2. Sugar Ray Robinson
3. Marvin Hagler (greatest middleweight of all time)
4. Sugar Ray Leonard
 
Goodieluver said:
Of the modern era of boxing, tyson dominated like no other, his only downfall was quality of opposition

QUOTE]

Goodie, you rascal, you stole part of my question!.... 😛

Wouldn't part of the determination of who was the greatest have to include the quality of all the competition and opponents faced?

I think anybody could get caught with a good clean punch (as James "Buster" Douglas taught Iorn Mike ) and have their ass hit the canvas, but who was the most skilled and effective boxer, and who fought the overall better quality of opponents over the course of their carreer?

I have heard a strong argument for Ali in this regard, but I do not know enough about the careers of some of the other boxers of times past to make a truly informed choice..... :ermm:
 
natural tickler said:
I would've said Tyson, but when he lost to Buster Douglas, that ended that. Ali would've never lost to a guy like him


Heh, ali did lose bouts to questionable boxers like trever berbick and ken norton
Granted none of em were carpet haulers like douglas but.....
 
jaba said:
Goodieluver said:
Of the modern era of boxing, tyson dominated like no other, his only downfall was quality of opposition

QUOTE]

Goodie, you rascal, you stole part of my question!.... 😛

Wouldn't part of the determination of who was the greatest have to include the quality of all the competition and opponents faced?

I think anybody could get caught with a good clean punch (as James "Buster" Douglas taught Iorn Mike ) and have their ass hit the canvas, but who was the most skilled and effective boxer, and who fought the overall better quality of opponents over the course of their carreer?

I have heard a strong argument for Ali in this regard, but I do not know enough about the careers of some of the other boxers of times past to make a truly informed choice..... :ermm:

Thing with tyson\douglas was tyson was severely undertrained for that fight and had alot of problems going for him at that moment. Also, tyson rarely went 5+ rounds so that was new for him as well and he just got woreout by a bigger stronger douglas but tech, tyson won that fight in the sense that douglas was floored in the 8th i wanna say and he was on the mat for 12-13 seconds

You are right in that its a tricky question based on "what do you define as good" Jake LaMotta was one of the best light heavyweights of all time but his style was literally the "Rocky" style cuz he could take more punishment than most, being known as having the best chin in boxing. Now i dont think just standing there and taking shots is skill but he also was clever in the ring which gives him merit to name him as a great

To me, Ali will always be a "what if", if he wasnt banned\have the vietnam\nation of islam issue, and continued to box, who knows where he coulda gone to, when he came back to fight foreman and other bouts, he was way past his prime. Ali certainly did have fluid movement and was possibly the best moving heavyweight of his time, but as i stated, i think more of jack dempsey and rocky marciano as being above him, specif dempsey as he became quite possibly the first anti-hero of the sports world and Rock was simply the rock

Jack johnson was also a great but its hard to calculate opposing talent then and now
 
Goodieluver said:
Heh, ali did lose bouts to questionable boxers like trever berbick and ken norton
Granted none of em were carpet haulers like douglas but.....


ah, that's the thing. I'll give ya Berbick, but Norton was among the good fighters of the 70's
 
I'm currently watching a documentary on the life and carreer of Ali.

Boy, he sure did brag and boast a lot, but how goes the saying?, "it aint bragging if you can back it up", and Ali backed up his bragging in just about every fight. His mental and psycological edge over his opponents were important elements in many of his bouts, sometimes just as important as his superior physical boxing skills...

And I believe if he had fought during some of his prime fighting years when he was banned from boxing, Ali may have slammed the door completely on any argument over who was truly the greatest boxer of all time...
 
MTP Jeff said:
I agree that it was Tyson. There was a lot more to him than just punching power, he was technically very skilled when he was in his prime, he had a lot of speed and precision, and despite his reputation, he had a formidable defense as well.

IAWTC, people tend to just write Tyson off as a monster puncher with little else to his game, but it wasn't his fault that nobody could live with his power long enough to allow him to show himself off. There was a lot of subtle stuff he did in his heyday that he lost as he got older and more insane, head movement and arm positioning, and he was bloody fast too.

Don't think he was the best boxer ever though. From what I've seen of Muhammad Ali (mostly old ESPN Classics fights and DVDs) I'd have to go with him; very smart fighter, quick and strong and full of heart, although I liked Nigel Benn when I was a kid though he was a mid/ super-mid rather than a heavyweight. Steve Collins too, he was a really entertaining fighter to watch. The yanks really missed something with him, he was superb, pure pressure and grit, and anyone who scares Roy Jones Jr. to the extent that he spends 18 months ducking challenges has to be a good boxer.
 
Muhammad Ali would have given Mike Tyson a hard time in his prime, and would have out lasted him after about 6 rounds. Plus, Ali had more quality opponents unlike the Earbiter. Ali v Fraizer bouts were epic events, and even Larry Holmes had more to offer including the fight against Clooney, and that fight in 1982 was the last great heavy weight fight.

Tyson was a pay-per-view circus bear who beat up stiffs, except when Buster Douglas finally downed him.

The sport is now a shell of its former self, even though I still love boxing.
 
The Greats boxer of All Time

Well even though this may meet with some very heavy disagreement
I don't think Mike Tyson should ever be considered as a great boxer of all time.

Muhammad Ali, Joe Frazier, and George Forman would've devoured him before the fifth round.

I'll give Tyson this much he was a power pouncher no doubt, but please don't be deluded to thinking he was the greatest of all time.

Personally speaking myself I dig boxers with class who don't beat on ladies to get their jolly's off, and that's pretty much why I'm an anti Tyson fan. But then thats just my opion of course.

TickleSlave07

Float like a butterfly
Sting like a bee.

Your hands can't hit
What your eyes can't
See
 
SamuelKhan said:
The sport is now a shell of its former self, even though I still love boxing.


well, I agree with you about the heavyweight division, but I think there are still some pretty good boxers and bouts in the lower weight divisions.....
 
Tyson knew how to box

He knew how to avoid hits and he learned discipline and control

You cant just take anyone and throw em in the ring and have em swing. Tyson was an unstoppable beast thanks to *******, its not surprising after his death, tysons career and mind went down the drain
 
Give me a Break

The way I see it Mike Tyson is a bum pure and simple who has no boxing skills what so ever.
If Mike Tyson and George Forman were ever to fight other Forman would burry Tyson in the middle of ring then go and get himself a pizza.

A Chump who couldn't fight his way of a wet paper bag with a hole in it.

Pleaseeee :sowrong:
 
jaba said:
well, I agree with you about the heavyweight division, but I think there are still some pretty good boxers and bouts in the lower weight divisions.....

Aye, looking at the heavyweight division nowadays is an exercise in head-scratching bewilderment. Aside from the Kiltschko brothers it's a who's who of nobodys and nothings. I also think it's odd that people only really dig around the heavyweights when they're talking about the best boxers evaire. I've always found the welter to super-middleweight divisions far more entertaining than the heavyweight division, though the fact British and European fighters have dominated those divisions for so long may have biased me somewhat ^_^.

If we're going outside the heavyweights for best boxers evaire then I'm going to put Joe Calzaghe's name forward. The man's an active, living legend; come this October he'll have been a world champion for 10 years and made 19 defences (20 depending upon when they schedule the fight against Kessler). The argument that he's fought nobody can't be levelled at Calzaghe either; I've never known him duck an opponent, even now when he's getting on a bit and isn't as explosive or aggressive as he used to be (although the stupidity with Robbie Reid is a bit of a stain on his career) and his wins have all come against quality opposition and include some of the best in the division including a bit of a stomping of Jeff Lacy. Bernard Hopkins actually jumped a weight division to avoid fighting him, and Bernard Hopkins was supposedly "Teh Greetest Evaire!!1" according to himself and his mum, and Jermaine Taylor seems to be less than confident of his chances against old Joe iven his reluctance to take a fight against the Welshman.

So yeah, Joe Calzaghe. The biggest crime in boxing history is Calzaghe's reputation in America; over the other side of the pond he's always been seen as a dark horse journeyman (despite having been world champion for all of 10 years) who nobody wants to risk themselves against, and now has the unfortunate honour of being "that British-Italian guy who beat up Manfredo from The Contender" which makes him seem a bit of a joke. He's really, really not, he's one of the most under-rated fighters in the game (outside Britain at least) and more than deserving of a mention amongst the all-time greats.
 
Goodieluver said:
Tyson knew how to box

He knew how to avoid hits and he learned discipline and control

You cant just take anyone and throw em in the ring and have em swing. Tyson was an unstoppable beast thanks to *******, its not surprising after his death, tysons career and mind went down the drain


Just curious, why is the name of Tyson's trainer\mentor a banned word?
 
The best Pound for Pound of all time.....
Featherweight champ from the 70s Salvador Sanchez HANDS DOWN
This kid was a brutal fighter Killed in a car crash while holding the belt SAD

Heavyweight ALI Tyson was a pip..he never could have outfought Ali
Light Heavyweight Mike Spinks
Middleweight Marvin Hagler...sorry to all the Carlos Monzon fans
Welterweight Sugar Ray Robinson..or Leonard pick one
Lightweight Roberto Duran....second best pound for pound
Featherweight Salvador Sanchez...you should have seen THIS GUY
Bantamweight Carlos Zarate.....Devestating puncher for 118lbs.
Flyweight Leo Randolf? I never followed the flies
 
sometimes, Ali couldn't see either.....

Well even though this may meet with some very heavy disagreement
I don't think Mike Tyson should ever be considered as a great boxer of all time.

Muhammad Ali, Joe Frazier, and George Forman would've devoured him before the fifth round.

I'll give Tyson this much he was a power pouncher no doubt, but please don't be deluded to thinking he was the greatest of all time.




Float like a butterfly
Sting like a bee.

Your hands can't hit
What your eyes can't
See


ha ha....i just watched footage of the Ali vs Sonny Liston fight....man oh man!....:xpulcy:

There was trash talking all around, and Ali's mouth was in the middle of it all! Most folks predicted Liston would easily knock Ali into the upper deck cheap seats in the first or second round. Sonny Liston pretty easily beat the great Floyd Patterson, setting up the Liston /Ali match up.....Sonny liston was a fantastic legit heavyweight champion fighter with a "lights out" punch. (kinda like "Iorn" Mike? 😛)

Ali was just about alone in his prediction that he would put Liston to sleep in the fourth round.....even Ali's corner thought he was cocky and crazy (which he was!)....

In the first few rounds, EVERYONE was amazed at how Ali danced and eluded and machine gun punched Liston, making it look effortless, and Liston, the Heavyweight champion, looked clearly frustrated and confused...Liston brought a sledgehammer to the fight, but ali brought a jack hammer, and used it with remarkable effectiveness.....

In the one round, Liston was cut pretty good below the eye, and his corner used a very effective but illegal and banned coagulating agent on Listons eye to stop the bleeding. Some how, whether intentional or accidentally, the substance got on Listons glove, and eventually got into Ali's eyes during the bout. Ali wanted to complain to the officials, and it was obvious watching footage that Ali had problems with his sight, constantly blinking and rubbing his eyes....Ali's corner told him that if he complained, the officials would stop the match, and Liston would be deemed the winner by default.

So Ali, while clearly blinded by something, was so elusive that he managed to evade and avoid a haymaker and bomb throwing Liston, until Ali's eyes cleared, and soon Ali went back to work and rapid fire punched liston until Liston was unable to answer the bell in the 7th round....

Folks, I dont know much about boxing, and I don't know who truly is the Greatest of all time, but I just watched Cassius Clay, at age 22, beat the legitimate Number one ranked hammer hitting reigning heavyweight champ......while blind. :bowing:
 
Ali

Cashes Clay, Cashes X, or Mahmmad Ali, what ever you call him he is the greatest of all time. If you don't believe me then just ask him. I would put George Chevalo in there for my Canadian Content, the toughest man never to be Worlds Champion.
 
What's New
9/25/25
Visit the TMF Welcome forum and take a moment to say hi to us!

Door 44
Live Camgirls!
Live Camgirls
Streaming Videos
Pic of the Week
Pic of the Week
Congratulations to
*** brad1704 ***
The winner of our weekly Trivia, held every Sunday night at 11PM EST in our Chat Room
Top