Top Ten NFL Quarterbacks Of All Time

[Illtcklu]

1. Joe Montana

2. John Unitas

3. Terry Bradshaw

4. Jim Plunkett

5. Roger Staubach

6. Troy Aikman

7. Brett Favre

8. Len Dawson

9. Bob Griese (NOT Brian!)

10. Dan Marino


....and everyone elses choices are...........

 

[Tickle Fiend]

1.Marino
2.Elway
3.Montana
4.Staubach
5.Aikman
6.Manning (Peyton)
7.Young
8.Brady
9.Farve
10.Bradshaw

 

[Illtcklu]

So Fiend05... I'm assuming that Manning is Peyton....... not Archie or Eli. There's so damn many Mannings you sometimes have to specify!

 

[CitY of MicA]

1. John Elway
2. Dan Fouts
3. Terry Bradshaw
4. Fran Tarkenton
5. Joe Montana
6. Ken Stabler
7. Roger Staubach
8. Bob Griese
9. Dan Marino
10. Peyton Manning


(only listing those whom I watched play- thus, no Unitas...)

 

[giantfan121262]

Marino
Montana
Elway
Unitas
Farve
Y A Tittle
Dawson
Staubach
Greise
P Manning

 

[RobAce]

Again here's my dollar and two cents worth.........

1. John Elway.

2. Joe Montana

3. Johnny Unitas

4. Dan Marino

5. Terry Bradshaw

6. Brett Farve

7. Troy Aikman

8. Steve Young

9. Dan Fouts

10. Warren Moon

Rob

 

[toyou444]

Gotta tell ya while I'm contemplating my list...I'm surprised (and happy) about the lack of love for Tom (My line didn't protect me during sex) Brady.

I figured the younger guys would have in the top two or three on every list.

~ toyou

 

[Dave2112]

Well, Brady should be on the list. Young guys voting or not, he's earned it. In this age of parity and with all of the changes in personnel the Pats have had, he just keeps winning. I think the Pats' success has more to do with him than Bill Bellichek's "genius".

I'm glad somebody added Fran Tarkinton. He basically created the concept of the scrambling QB, or at least made it work.

Warren Moon, anyone?

Steve Young should be on more lists.

And let's not forget Randall Cunningham. Ok, not maybe n a Top Ten all-time list, but he had one of the greatest single-seasons ever. All he did was come out of retirement and lead an undermanned Vikings team to a 15-1 season that was only kept out of the all-time history books by a bad kick.

All of that being said, if I had to, hypothetically speaking, put together a team to play against aliens or something for the Fate of Mankind, my QB is John Elway. And I don't even like the Broncos.

 

[Illtcklu]

Well, Brady should be on the list. Young guys voting or not, he's earned it. In this age of parity and with all of the changes in personnel the Pats have had, he just keeps winning. I think the Pats' success has more to do with him than Bill Bellichek's "genius".

I'm glad somebody added Fran Tarkinton. He basically created the concept of the scrambling QB, or at least made it work.

Warren Moon, anyone?

Steve Young should be on more lists.

And let's not forget Randall Cunningham. Ok, not maybe n a Top Ten all-time list, but he had one of the greatest single-seasons ever. All he did was come out of retirement and lead an undermanned Vikings team to a 15-1 season that was only kept out of the all-time history books by a bad kick.

All of that being said, if I had to, hypothetically speaking, put together a team to play against aliens or something for the Fate of Mankind, my QB is John Elway. And I don't even like the Broncos.

You're bringing up some good names, Dave!!! But having to pick only 10 it's tough, and though, I agree, the ones you've brought up are very good! I think they would have been sqeezed out! They're all really good 11's, 12's, and 13's!

 

[Illtcklu]

Again here's my dollar and two cents worth.........

1. John Elway.

2. Joe Montana

3. Johnny Unitas

4. Dan Marino

5. Terry Bradshaw

6. Brett Farve

7. Troy Aikman

8. Steve Young

9. Dan Fouts

10. Brett Farve

Rob

Ummmm you put Brett Farve on twice?!

 

[RobAce]

OOpsie.....I did put Brett Farve on twice...Ill be editing my post to include #10 being Warren Moon.

Sorry about that.....

Rob

 

[Dave2112]

Oh sure......steal my Warren Moon!

 

[RobAce]

Oh sure......steal my Warren Moon!

Ill see your Warren Moon and raise a Jim Kelly.

Rob