I got an interesting reaction while dating a very conservative petite 23 year old brunette girl that I met through a business associate. On our first date, she started questioning me about what I liked in girls. We were sitting across the room from each other for some reason I don't remember. I told her about liking feet, and she immediately pulled off her socks to show me her pedicured toes. They were painted red and her feet looked really soft and cute. I thought it was cool that she was so open with her feet, given how conservative she was. She started playing with her toes, as if she was getting the sock lint from between them. Then she asked what I liked to do with feet. I said, "You know, massage them, kiss them, tickle them".
"Eww, I don't like being tickled", she said. Her voice changed at this point, and took on a frightened tone. Then, she said it again, "I just, really don't like it". I was at a total loss for words, excited that she was that ticklish, but also concerned that she was so fearful. She kept playing with her toes while she was saying this, which made it even harder to concentrate. I just smiled and said, "Oh, ok", not knowing what else to say.
Then she said something out of the blue that I just couldn't believe. She looked at me with an accusatory look in her eye and said, "I bet you're one of those guys who likes to tickle people for a really long time, aren't you". I lied and said, "No, not really". Then she said, "Come on, don't lie, you're one of those guys who likes to tickle somebody until they just can't stand it anymore, aren't you". She continued to play with her toes while she was saying all this, with a disgusted look on her face, almost as if she was re-living some unbearable tickle torture she had experienced.
I was rock hard with excitement at this point, and at a total loss for words. We just stared at each other for few uncomfortable seconds before she continued. She said, "My last boyfriend, he held me down and tickled my feet once. I told him to stop, but he wouldn't. He just kept tickling and tickling. I really didn't like it at all. It was awful". I told her I would never do that, but I could tell she didn't believe me.
Then, she put her socks back on and turned the conversation to other things. The evening ended with no physical contact other than a hug and kiss on the cheek. I was rock hard the whole way out the door. Needless to say, I never got to tickle her. The relationship only lasted a few more dates, and she never let me near her feet the whole time.
