Bagelfather said:
Tickling is not the end all of things that I want in someone but it is a part of something I like. I think this goes for a lot of things that you want physically from a partner. In a more "vanilla" way you could ask the question "would you marry someone who wouldn't perform oral sex on you or vice versa?"
I couldn't have put it any better. I would have mentioned this before, but didn't want to stray from the main issue. But I agree with this statement, and that is why if I was with someone who couldn't stand tickling I would just 'walk a mile in their shoes'. Sympathy and Empathy play major roles in relationships, and compromise is paramount.
I am almost positive that there are one (or more things) that she was into that would not interest/arouse me, but I would attempt them if I were truly interested/in love with the woman. Hopefully, we could work together to understand each other's interests and stay together in the end; if not, it's too bad.
The main thing to consider is just how turned off the person of interest is by tickling and just how important it is too you. If you're into bondage, stocks, gags, toys, etc. it's probably not the best idea to try and go all out on someone who doesn't share the fetish. If they're willing to try, start small.
The way I see it, if the woman I'm interested in doesn't like tickling, that doesn't mean I have to STOP, it just means I can't tickle the sh*t out of her (or try to). A shame, really, but worth it if I really love her.
I hope I haven't rambled too much, as I tend to do or come across as 'preaching', as I'm only a young single and immature tickler and have much to learn from the matured ticklers on this site.
cheers