I can't really get caught up in what console games call RPGs. To me, a real RPG requires a tablefull of live people, a quick-witted GameMaster/DungeonMaster/Storyteller/Narrator, a clipboard full of photocopied character sheets, enough polyhedral dice to choke a frost giant, maybe some miniatures on a hexpaper map, a steady supply of Cheetos and Root Beer, and a vivid imagination. Final Fantasy XXIII (or whatever number they're up to) just doesn't have the same magic for me.
However, I can get caught up in 2-player slugfests all evening long. It brings back some of that social element that electronic RPGs lack. Many were the times my brother or I would clobber the other and dive right back into a rematch, pausing only to change characters. Some of my favorites include:
Iron & Blood: Warriors of Ravenloft for PlayStation 1. A D&D fighting game, with 8 good and 8 evil characters to choose from. I used to be well-nigh unstoppable with Sasha the Werewolf. My other brother traded it in without telling me, so I haven't played it in years and probably will never find it again. It's one to keep your eyes open for.
Soul Blade for PlayStation 1 and Soul Calibur for DreamCast. I like playing as Cervantes the Pirate once he's unlocked, and Ivy when I can get the hang of her sword/whip. (For some reason, I tend to gravitate towards playing the villains or the scariest female character. I'd like to think that this is because my brother always calls dibs on the main heroes, and not some deep dark subconscious reason.)
Armored Core for PlayStation 1 and Armored Core 2 for PlayStation 2. Ah, nothing beats custom-assembling a giant war machine and having a demolition derby with it. My favorite tactic is to use jump jets to get on top of a building and then rain down missiles on my opponent below. I'm rather annoyed by the new version's requirement of trudging through the one-player missions (the CPU cheats, I tell you) in order to unlock the components to build custom mechs in the two-player deathmatches, but I suppose that's what the game-obsessed 16-year-old brother of my buddy is for. "You're home all day this summer, could you get me enough parts to work with for the weekend?"
Is this discussion of gaming open only to the electronic variety, or can Pencil & Paper RPGS and tabletop miniatures wargames be discussed as well?