Battle of the former Genesis Singers

[socksoff]

Who would you rather see perform in concert:Gabriel or Collins?
(And we're talking song content and performance!)

He comes a rash of chick responses..........COLLINS!!!!

 

[ticklkitten]

I'm TORN with this one. But I'm going to have to go with Peter Gabriel just because well, Collins may have a better voice but Gabriel is brilliant.

 

[The Last Laugh]

As far as I'm concerned, no contest: GABRIEL

 

[MrMacphisto]

Collins... hands down... Gabriel is good, but Collins is better...

 

[sole seeker]

Yep, I'm gonna have to vote for Collins. Some of Gabriel's stuff was brilliant, but I think Collins was a just a touch better overall.

 

[steph]

Gabriel was amazing but I had the good fortune to sit in the 4th row of Phil's show~what an enigmatic talent...

XOXO

 

[Nige]

Both GREAT! in their own right. Though I was never a big Genesis fan, so will let the Genesis fans voice their opinion on this one.

 

[socksoff]

steph wrote:
Gabriel was amazing but I had the good fortune to sit in the 4th row of Phil's show~what an enigmatic talent...

CHICK!!!!!!

Did Phil have a giant clear ball to walk around in??!!!

 

[steph]

LOL~you so crazy for this! 🙂
XOXO

CHICK!!!!!!

Did Phil have a giant clear ball to walk around in??!!!

 

[ticklkitten]

All of the comments on here about Collins really made me think things over. BUT, Peter Gabriel has some insight into music that Phil doesn't. COllins tends to take more of a mainstream approach while Gabriel is more daring with his music. I guess I am more appreciative of someone who takes a risk and isn't afraid to try a new formula.

 

[socksoff]

ticklkitten wrote:
All of the comments on here about Collins really made me think things over. BUT, Peter Gabriel has some insight into music that Phil doesn't. COllins tends to take more of a mainstream approach while Gabriel is more daring with his music. I guess I am more appreciative of someone who takes a risk and isn't afraid to try a new formula.

Bravo!! Ticklekitty!!!!!!

 

[ticklkitten]

Bravo!! Ticklekitty!!!!!!

*bows* Hey, I speak the truth... but thank you.

 

[chode]

I have seen phil collins live twice. And out of any concert i have ever seen he is the best. He puts on awesome shows.

 

[Texas_Tickle]

Phil Collins, hands down. Don't get me wrong, Peter Gabril was good, but it was Collins who made Genesis a house-hold name.


Now Gabriel had better videos, IMHO.