Morning Angel said:
I've gotta say, G4's worse... *shudder*... Their voices just DO NOT work with rock songs.
No that's true, trying to cover a Freddie Mercury hit was a bad move. But at least these guys have a smidgin of talent. Steve is a decent singer, but the main reason he won was because Simon Cowell fiddled the computers that counted the votes. (The only possible explanation for such an abberation and staggering display of lack of taste on the part of the British public - it's a conspiracy I tell ya!)
I'll make a wee prediction now that Steve Beardie-Weirdy disappears just as fast as Michelle McManus did. She won the last Pop Idol and hasn't been heard of since. I suspect the reason for that is a rather shallow one. To suceed as a pop star you need to have looks that appeal to your target audience - as envy from your fellow sex and as a desireable shag by the opposite one. Michelle McManus doesn't. She's severely overweight. Shallow as hell I know, but I'm pretty certain it's true. It doesn't matter that she can outsing 99.999999999% of anyone on the planet and is otherwise very pretty. People won't buy her records because her physical image isn't appealing to the average record buyer. ( Listen to me talking as if I actually
know something about music!

) I suspect one reason she won the competition is because of the sympathy vote. People wanted to prove to themselves that appearance really didn't matter, so they voted her on. I'm pretty sure that's the same reason why Rick Waller originally lasted longer in the first series than Darius Danesh. (Not to mention that he then made a complete twat of himself on
Celebrity Fat Camp, when Harvey Walden nearly decked him.) Darius has more talent in one of his nuts than Rick Waller has in his entire body.
Unfortunately for Michelle, sympathy is a short lived thing. Once the public had salved their mass-conscience by voting her to win, they lost interest and she sank without trace. If I am right, I think it's desperately sad, but equally desperately predictable and Pete Waterman knew it, which is why he stormed out of the studio when she was announced as the winner.
I think a similar curse is going to send Steve back to Simon Cowell's arms, crying into his contract. The huge majority of shallow record buyers are young people. To be an average-half decent singer and sell lots you've got to appeal to them by having good looks, a good figure and charm their knickers off and Steve doesn't because he's bordering on early middle-age and has the world's worst taste in facial fuzz. He looks like a rat that's had a curtain rod jammed in it's arse and been used as a dishmop. (Hark at Brad Pitt's body-double here!) There is certainly a more discerning (and probably more intelligent) market of record buyers who're older, but Steve isn't good enough to appeal to them. I think at best he can look forward to 4-6 months of semi-fame, then he'll disappear. Sadly, Simon Cowell's smug fucking face won't go with him. The man is like herpes, you just can't get rid of him.
Jim - Who just
LOVES that scene in
Scary Movie3!