ANSWERS
Well, no one got the correct answer for all of the girls, however, i'm not entirely convinced there isn't at least some occurrences of being able to tell is a girl is ticklish or not but the fact that some thing said about these girls was spot on! The breakdown is as follows, including the spot on intuitions...
GIRL 1
This girl is very pretty, shy, yet has a flirty adventurous spirit, total GND, beautiful smile, beautiful feet. But when playing around with her a few years back, the ticklishness of a brick. She was good natured to laugh off my attempts instead of have the awkward, "what are you doing?" stare. Which made her lack of ticklishness all the more depressing. - Not Ticklish
1 is the girl next door, but has no to little ticklish feeling
1-Not so much. Certainly not as much as you want her to be.. and possibly not at all.. She'll be the one to answer "No"
GIRL 2
The last girl was a sweetheart about not being ticklish, this one not so much. An old friend of mine I was always curious about but wouldn't attempt as I didn't want my head knocked off. However, I did get to witness a overconfident smarmy young man try to give her a tickle, she responded by pushing away his hands and stating, "don't. I don't like to be touched" Probably thinking she meant, don't want to be touched because she was so ticklish, he went for it again, she didn't push away this time as to show she was not hiding a weakness. Just stood there, glared, and then slapped him across the face with a "I SAID DON'T TOUCH ME!" To reaffirm. I asked her later and she simply said, she's never been ticklish and even thought it was strange she wasn't because so many people are. - Not Ticklish
GIRL 3
I was lounging about with this girl after a good days work. She is barefoot whenever she can be so it was no surprise that she was now. This time, however, her feet were quite close to my hands. She is a real sweet-heart and wouldn't be mad and a little playfulness so reached over and gave her foot a little scrape. She just smiled and said, "You won't find any luck with that. I'm not ticklish anywhere, but I know you are!" And little wrestling around ensued and she was right on both accounts. - Not Ticklish
3 is ur classic Jane, she is probably a sweet heart but has the ticklish reaction of a dead cow.
GIRL 4
Was hanging out with a few work buddies on night. Someone busts out the iPod speakers and little dance party begins. I was showing off some pretty sweet moves and this girl, who obviously doesn't know a thing about dancing seemed to think they were anything less than the cat's meow. Well, little did she know, that you should never tease a tickler. I reached for her sides and she jumped! I held her close and dug in and she collapsed on the floor in a fit of giggles and scream. I held her bare foot under my arm and tickled her soft soles until she admitted she loved my dancing and was jealous of my skill. It's didn't last very long, maybe a few seconds... but enough 🙂 - Ticklish (Extremely)
4- Absent the visibility of her eyes, based on the laugh lines on this lovely I will guess Yes.
GIRL 5
Not much to say about this one, don't have a specific story, she's long standing friend of the family and for as long as I can remember, she has the ticklish of a brick. - Not Ticklish.