Edge said:
I always thought that the stereotype that men are soooooo shallow and think of women as objects and only go for the ultra hot supermodel type was true. However, I have come to find that young women in their 20s, compared to young men in their 20s...actually that women are more shallow, more picky, and more critical than men are. Anyone believe that?
I think what you're really observing here are the results of increased feminine independence. As the ability to support oneself through earning wages nearer to equal that of men increases, and the notions of feminism, "girl power" and the like proliferates, they will become more selective.
Women no longer have to nor are ensnared by the mindset that they have to be a homemaker, dependent upon the man. They can be breadwinners, too. Equal opportunity in the workplace affords equal opportunity in status, and permits broader selection among mates. They needn't (as much as in past generations) reconcile their feelings for a man with his income or resourcefulness. They have the opportunity to accept or dismiss potential mates on more nuanced characteristics. This may give them the appearance of being more picky, when they, like men, have been selective all along, but are only now awakened to the full, real freedom they have in mate selection.
The stigma persists that men are shallow and picky, since that's what stigmas do, but it is more (at least in my humble assessment) evidence that the genders are acquiring greater equality if they can both afford to be selective of potential mates.
Identifying current 20-something women as being the harbingers of shallowness is attributable to the fact that they are possessed of this increased selectivity, but perhaps may lack nuance in their selections due in part to age and inexperience. However, one should never overgeneralize to an entire population, as there are exceptions. We hardly live in a world of absolutes.
Equality in selectivity results in some unfortunate repercussions that also speak of gaining equality -- perhaps in ways not so desirable. For instance, the percentage of males suffering from eating disorders and body-image problems is on the rise, and will probably soon approach that of young women. This, I believe, can be tied to unrealistic expectations of physical fitness idealized by the increasingly selective female population ("My God! Did you see Brad Pitt's abs in 'Fight Club'?"), but the high numbers of women who've long held the record for eating disorders, body dysmorphic disorder and the like have dealt with this same thing ("Damn! Will you look at Jayne Mansfield?! Homina-homina-homina!") for decades longer.
Let women be selective. It's it's a sign of empowerment, I think, and it's about time.
If they're shallow, that's their problem -- not mine -- and not yours either, unless you're looking to snag a shallow girl.