In scorpion's defense, I've been thinking a lot about the whole confidence/self-image thing lately, for various reasons. It comes from within, but it most certainly comes from without as well; you can't really expect someone who's been abused, shit on, and rejected for their entire life to have a particularly healthy self-esteem or positive view of themselves and others; they're either going to think they're a complete waste of space and thus somehow deserve the abuse they're getting, or they're going to think everyone else is some kind of raving asshole for dumping on them unwarrantedly.
(Not saying scorpion is either of these extremes, I'm just spouting some generic examples.)
Take me, for instance. Lily can't understand why no one will date me. I don't understand it, either. In terms of self-image, I think I'm pretty damn great. I'm not a model, but I'm good-looking, especially for my age (no one ever believes I'm as old as I am). I'm college-educated. I play multiple musical instruments. I make good money (most of the time, anyway. I'm gambling on a startup right now.) I am, for all intents and purposes, a good person. I know my strengths, weaknesses, good points, and faults. I'm not overly angry, or abusive, or lazy. I'm not perfect, but I am human. I'm cool with all of this.
However, no one ever says yes when I ask them out. My only options are online dating, where (and statistics back them up) I will by virtue of being a male suffer a 10% response rate. Mine is actually lower than that, despite having a lengthy, well-written profile and some excellent photos taken by a near-professional photographer friend of mine. I do everything you're supposed to do that people say will make you appear favorably in terms of people wanting to date you. Except... none do.
Here's the funny thing, though; I have a vast amount of numerical data that supports the notion that, on a whole, women don't find me attractive. But if I say that, I get told I don't have confidence or self-esteem. Heck, you can wander back to that thread here about whether or not it's a good idea to compliment women on their feet in public, where I write at length about how interacting with people can sometimes feel like a guessing game that you get hammered at for losing, and Cif (female), chimed in with a snark about how it was "obvious" why no one wanted me.
You want a further mindfuck? My female friends like to post articles on Facebook from feminist websites, or rant about guys who approach them. You also see it on dating sites, where women complain about "come ons" from guys who clearly don't measure up to whatever standards they think they deserve. The message, then, is that these guys should clearly have known that she wouldn't be interested, and needs to be shamed for talking to her anyway. That stupid, clueless guy, they say, what possessed him to think I'd want his sorry ass?
What possessed him, indeed. Confidence and a healthy self-image, maybe? That guy thought he was worth her time. She disagreed. And, of course, her opinion mattered. His didn't.
We love to line up, point, and laugh at "clueless" people for not knowing their limitations; we don't watch American Idol to see who wins, we watch to see who Simon Cowell is going to rip a new one for. That idiot didn't know they couldn't sing? What planet do they live on, anyway?
And yet, at the same time, how many of those people were encouraged to follow their dreams, to go audition anyway, to have the courage and the confidence to take the shot?
I figured there must be something wrong with me. After all, I was all sorts of great stuff, but still, no one gives me the time of day. According to all these articles, and womenfolk, I must've been doing something to turn people off. So, I asked some folks close to me what it was.
Want to know what they said?
"The biggest reason people are turned off by you is that you think there's something wrong with you, but there isn't."
Let that sink in for a moment.
Seriously, think about it for a bit.
My problem is that I think there's a problem. Talk about circular logic. And yet, I only think there's a problem because I'm constantly being bombarded with the message that there is a problem from people who rant about people who don't think there's a problem.
Hey, fuck 'em, right? Who cares what they think?
In theory, that's a great idea, but if there's one thing I've learned, it's that when it comes to finding a relationship, it damn well matters what other people think, because you are trying to attract other people.
And, if I notice that a lot of people are rejecting me for vaguely silly, superficial reasons (my favorite so far is, "You play guitar? I don't like loud music. It wouldn't work out between us."), and I actually say "Hey, I'm meeting a lot of superficial, silly people...", what'll happen? People will trot out that tired, "point one finger, there's three pointing back at you" mantra. Because, clearly, it's my fault for them being that way.
(This is the part you should have skipped to if you didn't want to be arsed reading that whole thing.)
I think that when it comes to confidence and self-esteem, it's unrealistic to expect it to come fully from within. You can only work with what you're given, especially when one of the messages you're given is that you're a clueless moron if you hold an opinion that is clearly false - even if, to everyone you meet, that opinion is that you're a worthwhile human being. We really shouldn't immediately jump to the "You must be a loser" conclusion when people express having difficulties, especially when they sound angry. Of course they're going to sound angry. Or bitter. Or frustrated. That doesn't mean they have anger issues, and ergo that's why they aren't getting anywhere. The anger didn't come first, even if it may be perpetuating the situation now.
Anyway. Tying that back into the thread proper, I don't think scorpion's problem is entirely as cut-and-dry as "you lack self-esteem", or even my earlier comment "you're creeping them out". The truth, of course, is somewhere in the middle.