moonknight80200
TMF Expert
- Joined
- Jan 18, 2003
- Messages
- 301
- Points
- 0
Rgevskiy I agree with the bottom and the top of your list, it just gets dodgy around the middle...but like Kalamos said, we should not allow this to degenerate into a "my artist is better than your artist" thread, so I'll put down my pom-poms now and refrain from my continued chorus of "Snail, Snail, he's our man..." after simply saying that I've seen the guy's work improve drastically over the years and I don't see how anyone could rate it as just one slot above the "cack" guys on any list. Look at his early Marvel and JLU stuff and then the stuff he's posting now. A world of difference.
He's not the only one though. As others have said, Khali (her line art) and Chimp have gotten better too, while others (who have been posting for just as long if not longer) have not discernably improved at all. Their stuff looks exactly as it always has. I'm not sure what role constructive criticism or lack thereof played in any of that, but the kind of pointless "nice pic" fawning that Headsnap described could not have helped at all.
The issues raised by Webmaster Joe are quite valid, and I think those who wish to offer criticism or even (in the case of obvious drek) flatly state that a pic isn't very good should be able to do so without being labled as big heartless meanies or whatever.
Oh, and Headsnap said
"OH MY GOD THIS DRAWING IS CTHULUS ILLEGITIMATE SPAWN PLEASE BURN IT".
LOL! I know the feeling!
He's not the only one though. As others have said, Khali (her line art) and Chimp have gotten better too, while others (who have been posting for just as long if not longer) have not discernably improved at all. Their stuff looks exactly as it always has. I'm not sure what role constructive criticism or lack thereof played in any of that, but the kind of pointless "nice pic" fawning that Headsnap described could not have helped at all.
The issues raised by Webmaster Joe are quite valid, and I think those who wish to offer criticism or even (in the case of obvious drek) flatly state that a pic isn't very good should be able to do so without being labled as big heartless meanies or whatever.
Oh, and Headsnap said
"OH MY GOD THIS DRAWING IS CTHULUS ILLEGITIMATE SPAWN PLEASE BURN IT".
LOL! I know the feeling!



